Big fan of Sarah from Hello from the Magic Tavern and finally started listening. Too bad I hate wrestling, but I do enjoy these two knuckleheads. I live in Wisconsin too so yay new buddies!

The most refreshing and happy approach to Professional Wrestling. I love these guys and their motley crew of wrestling puppets. It's like getting a hug from Bayley in audio form. Update! Welcome back 5/30/2025 baybay🤘🏼

I still subscribe and hope for new episode to drop

Ducking miss this show!

I miss this podcast so much. It was such a bright spot for me for years, hearing other fans of pro wrestling talk positively about something we all enjoy. I hope Marty, Sarah and all the buddies are doing well. — Wordy McParticiple

I truly love this podcast and it has been such a light in so many darker times. I leave this feedback because I love it so much but it’s been feeling a little heavy recently with all that is going on in the world of wrestling. There used to be a joy (no pun intended, Sarah) that feels hasn’t been on the show in a few weeks. I kind of miss the positive light and definitely miss hearing from the buddies. I still wear my Wrestling Heart shirts with pride and love these two. Just want some of that old feeling back in the podcast.

Marty & Sarah love wrestling, that is a fact! (Spoiler alert…they also love each other!) They shine a positive light on the wacky world of professional wrestling. Come for the wrestling talk…stick around for the real life stuff. They are big supporters of mental health awareness, and have helped many of us in that respect. They are the best!

I listen to a lot of wrestling interviews on Highspots (Best $9.99 in the biz) and after hearing Marty & Sarah’s episode of Ego’s Amigos I had to check out their podcast. I must say, the chemistry in their relationship, their cute humor, and their knowledge of pro wrestling make this such a fun listen. Can’t wait to binge the back catalog. Meltzer 5*

Even if it’s a bad episode they’re gonna get their two mil. Five stars.

Do you wipe front to back or back to front? Your little buddy Nowaahhhh

Every week I can count on Marty and Sarah to put a smile on my face. They are so genuine, effortlessly funny and very kind people. Of all the wrestling buddies, my favorite is the Ghost of Andre The Giant and my favorite segment is Wrestling Confessions. I couldn’t possibly recommend this podcast more.

Love Marty & Sarah and all the “buddies” on the show! Always a fun listen and look forward to it every week!

Reigning and defending podcast champs!

Marty said to writes a review. I love him he’s a good boy. I love Sarah she’s great. I love Marty and Sarah love wrestling because they are cute together I don’t love their creepy Kurt angle doll as he haunts them. Please help them. Subscribe or they will be haunted Sweet community, awesome people listen if you love wrestling. I cannot give this 6 stars as apple wont allow me.

These guys are so funny and always have the best guests

I’m a new subscriber after jumping on at the 200th episode and I already love it. In a sea of negative wrestling podcasts and overly in-depth ones analyzing every little thing, it’s good to hear two people that are just normal genuine wrestling fans talking about what they love while also being entertaining and funny. I look forward to listening every week

Marty and Sarah will brighten up your week with their positivity and collection of wacky characters that will pop in at random times. This podcast always leaves me in a good mood, and has gotten me through a difficult time in my life. Every Friday I look forward to seeing that new podcast show up in my feed because I know I’ll be listening with a smile. Thanks buddies!

They just love wrestling so much, and hey, they try to look at the positive side of the business which can be pretty hard to do with such a divisive subject. I love all the buddies that pop in to say their piece (excepting Gerbert who can take a flying leap). They lift up my day during very difficult times, and offer an oasis of positivity and vibes.

Marty and Sarah really love wrestling! But more importantly they love podcasting and bringing the joy of wrestling to their listeners. The buddies are always fun when they show up, and add a nice spice to the show. Nathan is a vanilla bean. Gerbert is onion powder. Brad is an everything seasoning. And unkie Rick is pepper. Can't get enough of them and can't get enough of this podcast. Keep up the good work! PS Marty hope you enjoyed reading this in the loo, and remember to wash your hands for thirty seconds!

This show is a perfect showcase of the fun and joy in wrestling. I actually listened to this podcast for years before I ever watched episode of Raw or Smackdown. My fella and I gather around the Bluetooth speaker every week and giggle. Gerbert is my favorite and I will die on that hill. His friendship with Nathan is inspirational and a reminder that there are buddies everywhere

This is not the kind of wrestling podcast where the hosts look at wrestling with a critical eye. There are no match ratings, no debates about work rate, or analyzing promos. This is the kind of wrestling podcast where two goofy and affable hosts make silly jokes and celebrate the weird, wonderful world of professional wrestling. There are characters and bits, and lots of laughs. It’s basically being a part of a conversation with your two wrestling buddies, while their cats yell in the background...and it’s fantastic.

Love these two so much!!! I think if Marty and I lived near each other growing up we would have been best friends. His childhood antics mirror my own. These silly billys make my week every time an episode drops. It’s my goal in life to hang with these guys one day and maybe be a guest on the show

Hey Marty, you’re probably reading this while you’re poopin, just wanted to tell you. You and Sarah are doing a good job.

With all the negative and over analysis of wrestling out there it fun just put this on and remember why I’m fan of professional wrestling.

I ❤️ wrestling and I ❤️ Marty & Sarah! Please give it a listen!

I like wrestling too, Sweet.

The first thing one notices upon listening to Marty and Sarah Love Wrestling is how genuinely happy the hosts seem to be to record their podcast. There is no pretense of them trying to be disingenuous “broadcasters”, no radio voice, no veneer of sensationalism. When listening you can really tell that Marty and Sarah do indeed LOVE wrestling. The feeds are clogged with sarcastic, embittered, nerd rage filled wrestling “personalities” that ooze so much negativity and undeserved self assuredness that they are difficult to listen to. NOT THIS PODCAST! Marty and Sara are earnest, honest, engaging, and always in the end kind. There is real heart here, as there should be in podcasting; not salty minded headline grabbing sensationalism. The addition of the buddies is inspired, unique, and a highlight in every episode. If there was only one wrestling podcast on the feeds it should be this one.

Terrible Springsteen impression.

Humor is so good in this podcast. Both hosts are so likable. Hannibal impression had me rolling

Been listening for about 4 months now, and my crush on Sarah grows with every episode. If I ever meet her, I may try to steal her away!! Sorry Marty!! But in all seriousness, this is such a fun podcast. Marty and Sarah play off each other so well. Keep up the great work, buddies!!

Stumbled upon this wonderful podcast by searching through pro wrestling tees of all places, and I’m glad I did. This is a fun, fantastic, time passing podcast that I’ve been listening to daily. I’ve gone all the way back to the beginning and have loved listening to Marty, Sarah, and all the buddies.

One of my favorite podcasts ever. I always look forward to seeing a new episode every week! They’re great people and I love their takes on the business

It went from being such a fun wrestling podcast, but now it’s just Marty and Sarah flirting or talking about there life together. Also it seems like Sarah is just trying to get a writing job the whole time... Marty is the absolute best tho can’t say anything negative about him. He’s a world class comedian/ podcast host

My boyfriend and I fell in love with Marty, Sarah and all the buddies on a road trip from Detroit to Pennsylvania for an indie show last year. Tried finding something we’d both like and put this on... laughed entirely too hard the whole way there and back. I love this podcast.

I listen to a lot of podcasts, but there is only one that I consistently wait for it to be released and listen to every week the minute it is available on Apple Podcast: Marty and Sarah Love Wrestling! The hosts are so incredibly funny, they have incredible chemistry, and are able to riff with each other effortlessly. This podcast is a must for wrestling fans, but would be entertaining for anyone who likes to laugh and have a silly fun time! Brad the Alien and the Ghost of Andre the Giant are my favorite buddies!

Easily one of my favorite Podcasts! Two cool buddies talking wrestling and acting goofy. Really great stuff!

Remember when Mrs. Doubtfire gets her own tv show?

My favorite thing about Marty & Sarah (aside from their humor) is the approachability of this podcast. It isn’t overly technical or nerdy and perfect for the casual wrestling and comedy fan.

Marty and Sarah have brought our little family so much joy! Thorough yet digestible recaps of all the big wrestling shows we can hardly keep up with to introducing everyone to new talent, products, podcasts and buddies. This has it all. Even an alien! They straight up stay doing the Lord’s work. Sorry this is so long... We love you, buddies.

Marty and Sarah Love Wrestling is a refreshing, hilarious show that I anxiously await for every week! Been listening for about a year now and always catch myself laughing out loud while at work because of these two and all of their buddies on the show!

Great and funny podcast. Easily my favorite. It’s like the ghost of Andre gave this to Santa to give to all the buddies to brightened their day.

Marty and Sarah are the best part of my usually dreaded Thursday. I’m still not certain how they cram all those buddies into their apartment to record but I sure am glad they do.

They make a great podcast together

Started listening a few weeks ago and I am sooo happy I have a new podcast!!! And I’m even more excited that I have 100+ episodes to listen back to!! They constantly make me giggle and I love the buddies. Thank you!!

I love this podcast !!! so much fun ! everything on this podcast is so funny . impressions , improv , F , M , K too much goodness ! MUM!!!

Marty and Sarah have the most reliably joyous, charming, and funniest wrestling podcast around. They (and of course all the buddies) make Thursdays better and brighter by hanging out and talking wrestling, and even when I'm feeling less than inspired by wrestling, I never want to miss an episode. ❤️

Marty and Sarah bring joy to wrestling on a weekly basis. They never forget to protect the dot biz. They always make me laugh and smile. It’s my favorite podcast, maybe ever, definitely at this moment. Listen!

I’ve been a buddy since day one. I left a review of them a long time ago, but the podcast has evolved so much since they started, that it was time to leave another. Listening to their relationship go from two people who knew each other to the happy couple who act like a married couple and are #relationshipgoals has only made this podcast better. This is the best mix of wrestling and comedy and totally worth a listen. You’ll be hooked. Lord knows I am.

It's the perfect combination of my two favorite podcasts, We Watch Wrestling and Comedy Bang Bang. I will never get tired of "Ric Flairs" appearances on the show. I love hearing them talking about the wide world of wrestling. I can't stand the review podcasts that take everything too seriously and never seem to enjoy anything wrestling has to offer. These two are the complete opposite. I'm so glad I finally found another podcast I can truly look forward to hearing every week.

Love you buddies