I wish I would have gotten into this podcast sooner and I hope it gets renewed.

Oh my god, I love this podcast. Got here via Small Town and stayed for the laughs. I just watched the twilight movie with sound off while you guys commented and it’s the best time I’ve had in a long time. For a misanthropic introvert this was like having friends over for movie night. Perfect. Chef’s kiss. You guys make more of these please! P.S you’re such an awesome couple.

You guys are the funniest

You are both hilarious and feed off of each others jokes so well!

I love the energy Sarah and James share! This podcast is all love. I really enjoy hearing their takes on movies I both love and hate. I hope they’ll be posting some new episodes soon, but even going back and listening to episodes every so often is a treat

Super love STM and Crime and Sports- particularly fond of Jimmie(yeah I know you do the work James) and now I love this too! Sarah- you’re also hilarious and lovely.

love sarah and James !

Found this podcast through Small Town Murders but Ive been bingeing this now. So funny. Such a great couple.

😍

Great show! Please come back!

Love this show!! Thought I’d check it out after he’s about it on Small Town Murder. It makes me rethink all the RomComs I’ve ever watched.

Found this gem after listening to James on Small Town Murder! I do not enjoy romantic comedies whatsoever, so finding a podcast that discusses the exact reasons I hate them is AMAZING! James and Sarah have me cackling with laughter daily. They have the best chemistry and the banter between the two puts me in a great mood. If you’re looking for a comedic discussion of horrible movies, I highly recommend!

Just following instructions Seriously, it’s a great funny podcast

Please come back!!!! I need to hear James loose his mind on more movies!! It would be hilarious to have Jimmy on the show.

You didn’t get the female part. She was trying to lose a guy in ten days. She did all the things that women are accused of doing that are crazy.

Please. Come. Back.

There are so many bad movies!!! Very funny.

A fun and meaningless (in the best way!) podcast! Perfect when I need something a little lighthearted. I just wish they would come back.

Came late to the podcast, can’t wait to listen to them all

What happened to the podcast!? Love this and need so much more!

I wonder if this show would have been more successful if Sarah knew the difference between Larissa Oleynik and Melissa Joan Hart, but in an attempt to be funny Sarah referred to Larissa Oleynik as “Clarissa Explains it All” during the whole 10 Things I Hate About You.

And I would love more episodes!

Love, love, love this movie. You guys are great! James tell me you liked Teen Witch as well, or was that too corny? Beginning of the 90’s… and you guys did it. Just found it!!!!YES

Easily one of my favourite podcasts. It is fun to witness the relationship dynamic between these two brilliant people. They have some fantastic, and funny, insights into the bizarre world of romantic comedies.

Y’all got me laughing so hard at these. I can’t wait until they release more!

Good show. Found this from listening to small town murder.

Sarah, we miss you, please come back!

I love this podcast so much! Please do more movies!! 😎

Miss it, hope it comes back soon.

These two are so cute together. I love rom-coms but I’m well-aware of how stupid they are so this podcast has been a real treat.

You guys are hilarious! Please keep the show going. I would love to know what you think of Just Like Heaven.

Your review of “Love, Actually” was awesome! I hate that movie! I love you guys!

Sidle up and enjoy the show - one of the best podcasts out there

Yep

These two are hilarious!!

Trying to think of something witty isn’t working.

🔥 🔥 🔥

I hope you come back again…I’m leaving you in my follows so I don’t miss it if/when you do!

As a screenwriter and independent filmmaker I love this podcast more than any other. I recommended it to one of my friends whomis a producer on Romantic Comedies, and got her hooked too. I give this negative 5 heigls

Love your show

Really like this podcast …. Is it dead tho ?

I am new to this show, but a fan of James other shows. James and Sarah discuss certain movies from their point of view and keep you entertained.

Great job guys! I wish you would do an episode on Because I Said So feat Diane Keaton and Mandy Moore. Laughed out loud during the Pretty Woman episode.

I love hearing the two of them interact, they are both hilarious. I want to go watch movies with them. 🤣 I want to add to my review and say I really enjoy having this as a podcast to listen to when I need a break from true crime. I also love it when they do a movie that I’ve never seen, it makes me glad I never watched them.

Hilarious. Inconsistent schedule at times, BUT these people have other work going on, so I welcome the surprise when it pops on my feed.

Are you finished making this podcast? A note that you’re done would be considerate.

Enjoy the podcast…but could you develop a schedule? If you’ve only got time once a month, then that’s it, it’s once a month…but it would be nice to know when.

I love Sarah and James. And I LOVE PS I Hate This Movie. I cannot get enough of this show. Negative one million Heigls for this podcast! Don’t know what that means? Then listen to this show, NOWWW.

Found it very funny. Thanks for not talking politics or any other nonsense. Just funny takes on movies. Great job

I love listening to James and Sarah. They mind me so much of how me and my husband watch movies. The groans James make crack me up! Sarah’s giggles at James’s antics are also great! Have been a Crime in Sports and STM listener forever. So glad to have this too.