Love the podcast! 3 notes: -Would appreciate it if Erin could turn her microphone down a bit - it’s reading as a lot louder than Mary Payne’s. -Nobody would notice the throat clearing or coughing if it wasn’t so frequently announced and discussed it at length. -The interrupting and talking over Mary Paine is happening a lot more than it used to. But ya’ll are hilarious and wonderful and please know that I look forward to episodes even if there are repeated announcements regarding throat clearing.

Despite Mary Payne’s statements about not being political, she’s a very woke liberal and political. Not even realizing that we have an open border due to our current “president”, it’s being flooded with criminals, diseases (Covid, TB, leprosey to name a few) and these people are then released into the US, unvaccinated, and unmasked - her comments are just nothing short of liberal hypocrisy. If I wanted to hear that I’d turn on CNN. And if you politely remind her that she’s out of her realm and misinformed, she blocks you. Nice way to treat the people paying your bills! I guess you don’t need us- fine by me! We had a weekly podcast listening group of several women that would get together and listen over wine but we are all VERY turned off by Mary Payne’s rude and arrogant beltway (Washington DC) attitudes. Her husband works with the DC types. Can you tell? Good luck, you just lost a bunch of listeners.

Welcome back Erin. I love this podcast. One of my favorites is Kimberly as roving reporter on Life After Lockup--very funny!

Mary Payne and the guest hosts brought this podcast back to life… it’s back on life support with Erin being back.

I found this podcast after hearing Erin guest on 90 Day Cray Cray and it has become my favorite. Genuinely funny recaps of trash tv. I even listen to recaps of shows I don’t watch, and find those episodes just as good.

Love this podcast. The hosts are so real and funny to listen to! They recap all my favorite shows and give me a seemingly never ending supply of content. Love you MP and Erin ❤️

You guys are AWESOME!

These ladies are totally authentic, hilarious and full of heart. Erin & Mary Payne are true Besties and lift one another, along with their “Bunkies” up fearlessly. I tune into every single episode and rely on this wonderful community for all of my dumpster fire pop culture recaps and recommendations! Thank you for your SERVICE 🙏🏾💓🙏🏾

Love you both!!! Hilarious!

Not only does Mary Payne deliver the carefully transcribed dialogue artfully, her attention to the minute and fascinating details is fabulous.

Love this podcast.. I stopped watching Love After Lock Up (I just couldn’t anymore - LOL) but I really don’t need to because Erin & Mary do a fantastic job recapping. Thank You for making me laugh!

So glad to hear Erin back on the podcasts. All of the fill-in podcasts were fantastic, but so happy to hear Mary Payne and Erin back together again.

Love Kimberly and Keisha so much!

I simply cannot listen to any more podcasts with Kimberly as a guest host. Her constant interruptions are driving me crazy!!!!!! So rude.

All I can say is MPG is either money hungry or in financial trouble. She talks quite a lot about advising people how to charge listeners more $$$. It’s not a good look. How about advise privately so the rest of us don’t get the impression you are desperate to drain us.

Have her back as much as possible

If you like Watch What Crappens for bravo you’ll love these ladies for all things TLC and sometimes WETV (and also some bravo). They cover all the 90 day franchise and Love after Lockup (and sometimes a bravo round up). They are fantastic. 5 stars. 10/10.

Smart and funny. Great shady stories. This is my sports

These ladies are amazing! So relatable and fun!

Funny, relatable, and the recaps are great. Love Erin and Mary-Payn’s vibe! (Also love the guest hosts!)

Love this podcast and the hosts. I feel like I’m listening to friends ❤️

One of my favorite recap podcasts! But the guests lately have been not so great. Specifically the newest one with Rebekah on her high horse the whole time. So awkward. Sounds like I’m listening to a lady with a stick up her butt clutching her pearls talking about the Housewives. I’d rather not listen to someone being so judgmental and stuck up talk about my trash Bravo shows.

5 stars to combat Carole.

Highlight of my week!! Thank you Pink Shade!

I’ve been listening to this podcast for a few years and it is always so funny and endearing. Thanks Mary Payne and Erin. Hope Erin is able to return soon!

Love the recaps of bravo shows! So witty and enjoyable!

These podcasts are just plain fun. I love Mary Pain and Erin, my fellow Wisconsinite. And even though I miss Erin, all of the guest hosts like Kimberly and Keisha (she was hilarious) have been awesome. Y’all keep me wanting to watch these trashy show just so I listen to this podcast afterwards. Keep going! Us stay at home moms need to the laughs.

These two constantly have me laughing. It’s been amazing that Mary-Payne has been handling all aspects of the podcast while Erin take a much needed health break. Do I agree with them 100% of the time? NO. That would be weird but I feel like I am talking to my girlfriends when listening. Keep up the good work!

LOVE Kim

I have started listening to these ladies a few months ago which led me to several other podcasts that I love!!! They are very Funny and they have become my guilty pleasure! Thank you for all you do!!! Erin, you are missed! Well wishes and make it back soon! Shout out to MP for holding it down!!!

This podcast has been a lifeline during the past two years. Erin and Mary Payne are so funny and relatable. Kudos to Mary Payne for keeping up the energy and continuing to post great content. 💙

What’s up with guest hosts that don’t actually watch the show they’re hosting?!? Geez, it’s getting painful since we, the fans don’t need a crash course in the shows we’re fans of watching.

I like MP but honestly an episode is basically her regurgitating the entire episode of whatever she is recapping word for word. There is no need to repeat literally everything in an episode and everything every person says. We all watch the episodes so we don’t need to hear every single line again. I want to like this podcast, I really do. I hope it gets better.

Mary and Erin are fixated on “mouth holes” (poor dentistry), and mock people when they don’t meet their standards. Ladies. You are from the US and should know that dental care is very expensive. Did you know that only 50% of the 18-64 yr population have private dental insurance? It’s classist to publicly shame those of us who have to choose between perfect smiles and true life necessities like paying our mortgages, rents, food, etc. You may not be able to control how you feel, but you can control your own mouths by not making shaming public statements about “mouth holes”.

Erin and Mary do such a good job covering a variety of topics and shows! The guests they bring on are awesomeI would recommend this podcast to anyone looking to be entertained and informed!

Can’t we escape it on a stupid podcast?

Loved the recent episode with Crazy In Love. They had a great perspective. Keep up the awesome work MP.

I love 90DF and Darcey and Stacey. I usually only listen to Reality Gays, but now I also listen to this one. I even went back and listened to older ones because I love it so much. I'm also from the south, love southern MP. But I love Erin too and their conversation about no longer being able to just hoist themselves out of the pool made me almost run off the road I laughed so hard. I can't afford it, but I did the $5 patreon just to hear them discuss Darcey and Stacey. 5 stars, love love love!

So excited to see you had Tereza and John on. Started listening to them recently and the three of you together were wonderful!

I love this podcast! Much love from this Alexandria, Va native

Listening to Mary Payne’s coverage of Love Island isn’t the first time I’ve heard the religion of my birth called a cult. I have been a Patreon subscriber for years. I am offended. I would like to talk about this and the unfair portrayal of my religion. Respect should be paramount. I cannot, in good conscience, continue to listen to a podcast that defames my faith and categorizes it in a defamatory manner. Please, let’s rectify this.

Mary Payne and Erin have great chemistry together. Love them and look forward to all their recaps! Sending positive vibes to both ladies while Erin is away. 💜💜

Just found this podcast so I’ve only heard Mary Payne. Mary is so funny! I needed someone who breaks down Love after Lock up. So glad I found it!

I recently found your podcast so I’ve only heard Mary so far and she’s so fun to listen to. I loved the podcasts w ben and then Ronnie. I can’t wait to continue listening. So glad I found you.

Erin and Mary are so fun to listen to. I love the way they recap 90 day- the stories they tell about their everyday home lives makes me laugh- esp when they talk about funny things with aging. Thanks ladies for all the fun! And Poodle- you KILLED it this week with your Natalie. Spot on!!

These women can brighten any day with their shady commentary on our fav tv shows!

I love this podcast soooo much. I did not love Linda from the melanated way though. She took everything way too seriously! It is a tv show sis, loosen up! Erin and Mary Payne are so good together. It was painful listening to Linda. Stick to co hosts that have a sense of humor and don’t take this so seriously like it’s life or death.

How have I never found your podcast until now?! You all watch all of my favorite shows (especially Love After Lockup - AKA TV's hidden gem)!! So excited to start listening to your reviews weekly! I gave up on Happily Ever After around ep 3 this season because of how EXTREMELY fake/scripted it has become but I will be glad to listen to your reviews still!!

Love you both! Each day I look forward to hearing you two talk. I always get a giggle and love your content. You are my number one!! Thanks for being there for us. Feels like we are all family and that’s because of you. Thank you!!

I started reading Erin Martin’s recaps of 90 day fiancé online. Once I found myself spending more time in the car, I decided to check out her podcast - my first podcast! That was life changing! Erin is so snarky and funny. Now she and Mary Payne Gilbert are Sister Wives For Life as co-hosts of Pink Shade. They are hilarious together (and separately) The dynamic duo focuses on the 90 day fiancé family of trash tv (all 7000 spinoffs) and the prison “lockup” series but does touch on a few other shows such as the Housewives. Pink Shade also has a facebook community that is beyond anything I could have ever imagined. We support each other and look to each other for advice. I live for Tuesdays when I know that Pink Shade will be waiting in my podcast downloads.