Fun, informative, and engaging. These guys ride the wins and losses with the rest of us. I always love listening after a match to “debrief”. Plus, the discord community is a great bonus. Since I don’t have Everton fans around me, I love checking in on the mid game chatter on the discord channel. It’s like a watch party! Keep it up, guys!

The best team-specific podcast I’ve found. A perfect balance of technical and tactical analysis, but clearly from a fan-first perspective. An essential listen for any Everton fan that really catches the Spirit of supporting the club.

As being an American Everton fan now for about 15 years and what I consider lack of knowledge of football (soccer), I appreciate the the depth you gentlemen go into the analysis of our club on every level. Thanks

Very in-depth views that are not knee jerk or prisoner-of-the-moment in the slightest! Thanks for all your work in cultivating this American-based community.

Once the bastion of objective tactical breakdown for Everton games. Sadly, this season the podcast spends far too much time sniping & barracking the officiating, it's neither objective or informative, once a hallmark of their production. I hope they reset and get back to what made this podcast stand out.

Balance between technical analysis and fandom. Rarely meatball-esque blind fandom. Would be great if they added videos.

This review is left for James, as he demanded.

Enough love for the club with just the right amount of detachment to distinguish it from some other podcasts. Ryan is the reason you listen as he has extra tactical knowledge of the game. He may come across as overly assured, dismissive of others’ opinions, and a non-Everton supporter at times, but you get past it. James moderates a great show. Listen at 1.5x speed.

Ryan, James, and Alex are passionate Evertonians that do a great job of being objective and discussing all things Everton. Major credit to them for always being on top of it especially these past two seasons. In my opinion, the best Everton podcast out there. Up the Toffees!

I LOVE this show. As an American Toffee and the closest supporters club being 5 hours away. I at least can get my fix.

Used to enjoy this show but it’s gotten really stale. Seems to be a vehicle for Ryan’s ego and rarely entertains anymore. Needs some new guests and a format that isn’t so bland. Miss the early days with James and Alex.

In a season like we’ve had this year it actually calms me greatly to listen to Ryan and James break down post match win or lose. Essential listening for me, only down side is I only get one a week. Anyways, can’t recommend enough, keep putting out the excellent content! UTFT

I am new into the EPL and into Everton but they make it easy to understand but also add in interesting stats to help me learn even more. Really love the pod and their discord!

The right measure of stats and analysis on the one hand and passion and fandom on the other. The guys are a regular listen after each game. Keep up the good work, fellas.

These guys are great. A go-to listen after matches. With lots more. Light on the hot takes, heavy on level-headed grounded analysis from a royal blue perspective.

Even-handed reviews of Everton performances and players. They are fans but they keep it together when things don’t always work out as we’d like. Do miss the founder, hope he is doing well.

Found this pod as it started out as I was looking for an outlet for my Everton fandom. It has continued to grow into an integral part of my match days and look forward to see how far they go!

great analysis, insightful commentary, passionate hosts: what more could you want? up the toffees!

These guys rock! Bring excellent into all things Everton. UTFT!!!!!!!!

This is the premier podcast for American fans (or any fan) of Everton - very good tactical discussions and analysis that go far beyond the typical soccer pod.

Amazing podcast for any toffee fan, especially any American toffee fan. Up the toffees!

Saw the pod had 99 reviews and thought... I’ve listened to pretty much every episode from number 1 until now, I should probably drop a 5star on this thing and return some of the love. Great pod to make stateside Toffees feel like they’re part of the larger group of Evertonians. Alex, James, and now Ryan do a great job breaking down matches, previewing stuff and talking potential transfers.

Depending on where you live in the states, it can be easy to feel isolated as an Everton fan. ATP gives a great sense of community for American Evertonians with their quality analysis, coverage, and discussion. UTFT!

Best Everton pod available by far

Keep up the great work , COYB!

Definitely will be a follower. Keep up good work.

Alex and James do a fantastic job of covering all the Everton topics. It's great to hear Everton fans talking Everton.

Alex and James are very knowledgeable about Everton FC and soccer in general. They do a great job communicating this in a fun way without ranting. They also started a discord for us fans to have some banter throughout the week. Major funs.

Love this podcast and the community that James and Alex have built with not only the podcast but the discord chat as well. Both guys go out of their way to connect with other American Toffees and get other American Toffees connected. This is a must-listen Podcast for Everton fans and fans of Premier League in general.

5 stars from your friends over at Mostly Soccer! Great pod.

Alex has a great listening voice and I really enjoy listening to what they have to say about soccer.

Interesting discussion from a passionate American Everton supporter.

Great podcast

Definitely feel like I’m better then this guy at soccer, but the mid table team commentary’s is very dope!

Great Podcast! He speaks clearly and is very knowledgeable about Everton. Solid 5/5

This is the first Everton podcast that I’ve come across, and I’ve thoroughly enjoyed both episodes thus far. It is both concise and extremely informative, which makes it easy to listen to. Definitely worth a shot if you are an Everton fan or a soccer fan in general.

Alex is a natural. His presentation is well organized and highly informative. He covers Everton with a sincere passion, but also manages to provide valuable insight throughout. Whether you are a fan of the club, football, or just sports in general, I am confident that you will enjoy this podcast as much as I have.

My dog loves this podcast

Although Chelsea FC is a far better team than Everton, this Podcast is a must listen. Unlike most people who don’t know what they’re talking about, this guy is very knowledgable on fútbol. Doesn’t get better than this folks.

I am personally an American Everton fan and this podcast has it all. It is thorough and you can tell a great deal of thought and effort was put into it. Easy to listen to and quite informative!

Great content and knowledge. I can’t wait for the next one!

Great show! Looking forward to future episodes, think about getting some better recording equipment.

Wow just wow!

Not a huge soccer fan but this mans knowledge of the game is unmatched. I would recommend this podcast to all different types of viewers, it is simply incredible.

Great start looking forward to future episodes! Definitely do think guests should be added into show too.

As a budding soccer fan and podcast enthusiast this gives an interesting take on the American viewpoint of the EPL, definitely excited for more

Not too many Everton podcasts out there to begin with, let alone an American one, which allows for a fresh and different perspective. Simple, yet knowledgeable, and would recommend to any Evertonian or fan of the EPL.

I don’t normally listen to podcasts but I heard about this topic and I was very interested since I don’t know much about Everton. But his voice clarity and knowledge about the team as a whole was awesome to hear. I would definitely recommend that you subscribe and try and listen to his stuff! 10/10 would listen again.