Listening to these 2 sisters and occassionally, their mom, talk about their found footage story is great! It's a unique way to tell a story and you should go listen!

Fascinating concept that blends fact and fiction so well you're never really sure where one ends and the other begins. Part true crime part thriller story that draws you in right away presented in a decpetively casual friendly way. Great hosts with good chemistry really help sell it. I'm binging!

Such a cool concept, and expertly executed. It has the love and chemistry between hosts that you look for in a non-fiction podcast, plus the unrestrained creativity of the best fictional podcasts. It’s a perfect marriage!

Love this so much. The concept is uniquely dark but fun. Expect an email from me at some point! - April from All Cats Are Grey in the Dark

I love true crime and horror podcasts so I’m always on the lookout for new ones along those lines— Dear Murder Street scratches that itch but with SUCH a unique concept, I’ve never heard anything like it. Equal parts hilariously entertaining and genuinely terrifying, this show blurs the lines of fiction and reality in a way that really sticks with you. Can’t wait to dig further into the catalog!

Dear Murder Street is an exciting podcast because of the hosts' background of Murder Street! That alone draws the listener in but it is the sister's chemistry that allows this podcast to be thrilling and fun. I'm a new fan!

I recently started following the ladies on Twitter (I'm a podcast addict) and finally settled in to check out their first episodes. What an interesting concept! Totally not what I was expecting and both ladies are excellent storytellers. Great production quality and interaction between hosts and their contributors. I will definitely be recommending this to friends who like "Welcome to Nightvale" and other murder-esque shows!

What a creative and "unique" concept! I love it! I listened to your intro episode and I was instantly intrigued! Of course I then listened to some more! Meg and MJ do a fantastic job with their storytelling and their interaction with one another is very entertaining! You definitely have another listener/fan!

Meg and MK (IF THOSE ARE EVEN THEIR REAL NAMES) talk so convincingly about these stories that sometimes you wonder what is real and what is ficiton? It seems so unique to include different ways for the audience to get involved in telling the stories. Start at the beginning and once you catch up, join in on the story!

I love the format and I love the concept. I love the twist in the first episode and I love the skeptic/believer dynamic of the hosts. The show uses a format that totally works in podcasts and makes everything seem so real and believable. I even googled John Dearborn to try to learn more...

Dear Amazing Podcast, Your podcast brought my attention in like breaking news. I couldn't stop listening to your stories and the ti- ins about your childhood are like sprinkles on a cake! The story about Mr. John Dearborn is INSANE, but if anyone needs to report on a murder, it's you :-) Fellow readers, this is the show to listen to!

Or maybe it is! Because Dear Murder Street is fantastic - such an original concept, excellent storytelling, engaging hosts! If you haven't listened yet, definitely start at the beginning so you can get all the great backstory and catch references and nuances in the newer eps.

This podcast is such a great concept and a fun way to explore the paranormal & true crime. The co-hostess’ banter is a delight. It’s fun to imagine with them. Keep it up!

The girls have set the bar in the True Crime pod world. You listen and then you can’t stop...it’s now four episodes later you realize you’re hooked. Funny, interesting. Sit back and enjoy the pod. You’ll have no regrets.

Y’all....this podcast is as funny as it is entertaining!! I was hooked after the first episode! I love how the Carroll sisters (Meg and MK) have such hilarious debates on whether or not spooky things exist!! And, as an added bonus..(even though the stories are pretend) I learn something from every show!! Like, about the “Thin Place”......and, unfortunately, Merlin’s real story!! 😂 Also, that a man lived in the walls in the house next to them...WHAT??? Everyone should be listening 🙌🙌🙌🙌

I’ve just started getting into mystery crime podcasts, and I’m getting a sense of the different ways it can be done. This one doesn’t take itself too seriously, which keeps it light-hearted and cute.

This is a good podcast but one of the ladies repeats her self a lot.🙁kinda annoying.

Drop all your plans. Settle in. Turn out the lights. Fully submerge yourself into this story. You won’t regret it. Maybe you’ll regret the lack of sleep—no you won’t. It’s totally worth it. Hearing all the pieces fall into place leaves you wanting more. My only complaint is that I can’t listen to this for the first time again.

This Pod immediately reminds me of campfire 🔥stories about ghosts 👻and hooked hand murderers. These two sisters weave a tale so convincingly it's hard to tell where fiction begins and ends. For anyone who enjoys spooky stories or true crime this is a can't miss show! 🗡♥️

This is a really fun show & I love that the hosts have great energy! The cases they look at are super interesting too.

This podcast rocks! Immersive story and great production quality, I’m hooked.

I found this podcast through Haunted Happenstance, and I immediately fell in love with it! I love the idea of listener participation and Meg and MJ’s banter is great. Season 2 can’t come fast enough!

Very impressed with how much detail goes into this show. I like learning about true crime and find paranormal things interesting. Plus I love the fact that the hosts are sisters and have great banter.

I wish that I had the idea for this show! Not that I could do it so well. I’m usually too much of a scaredy cat to enjoy horror itself, but the Carroll sisters have an easy going likability and a comfort with the macabre that makes it easy to let your guard down. It’s like I got tricked into listening. And now I've had disturbing images stuck in my head for weeks (and know more about demon babies). You got me. Thanks!

Good stuff, great concept, and very well produced!

We love the concept of this podcast. Allow the Carroll sisters to take you to a world of make believe that will give you a real fright! Subscribe and listen now!

These ladies are wonderful! This a wonderful podcast and it is easy to forget that it is fictional when listening!! Meg and MK do a wonderful job and this is for sure a must listen♥️

I always appreciate shows, especially those within this field, that have hosts that contribute their own thoughts and experience into their subjects. With these sisters you get just that! Some awesome topics, commentary and discussions, that really elevate this show above others of its kind.

That’s a thing. And anytime someone says “i don’t go in my attic” I’m going to tell all about John Deerborn 😬 great approach & format!!!

I really can't say enough about this show. It's amazing. The writing is great, the stories, production. It's an instant draw in from episode one and it's really hard to believe it's an audiodrama! You guys are doing a great job, keep it up!

I very rarely listen to fictional podcasts, but I’m so glad I decided to check this one out. It’s a great combination of creepiness and fun, and every episode is different so I never get tired of the “podcast formula.“ I’ve got several loaded up for my next long trip. Keep up the great work!

Even though these stories may be fictional, the legends and folklore and things I learn from this podcast had me hooked! Now I can't stop listening. The sisters witty banter really keeps you in. Would recommend to anyone that's into true crime and the paranormal.

I was so surprised that this was actually an audio drama because the first episode was so awesome and organic and interesting. It’s a really interesting topic and I can’t wait to come back and listen to more!

I love podcasts where I feel like I’m just listening to my friends, and this podcast nails it! I definitely wish I grew up on murder street too!

Another #ladypodsquad out here killin’ it! (Pun intended). Great dynamic between the Carroll sisters and just an all around engrossing pod to spend some time with.

I gave this pod a listen, I don't generally listen to anything besides non-fiction crime podcasts and I adore this podcast. I love the easy flow of storytelling the sisters have. Their in-jokes and shared memroies with different perspectives are quite charming. This is an easy podcast to love and kind of make you wish you grew up on Murder Street ;)

Dear Murder Street tackles the dark and macabre. However, what sets it above most is the rapport between the two sisters and engaging nature of the show itself. It should be mentioned that these type of topics are always fascinating to listen to. This might be the first true crime, paranormal, etc show I’ve listened to with insight provided between siblings, and it’s quite effective. Give them a listen and subscribe!

A great show with a great concept. I love the stories and the advice. The hosts do such a good job!

LOVE IT

Dear Murder Street is such a great twist on murder podcasts! (I mean, I call them murder podcasts.) The hosts are awesome and creative. I highly recommend!

I love the dynamic the sisters bring to the table and the format of the show is like no other pod I've listened too before. Great stuff. Keep up the awesome work.

Love the set up of this show. Tuned into the most recent ep (the ASMR one). Keep it up ladies!!

I just started listening to this show and I am already hooked! These ladies have a unique story, give great advice, and have that lovable sibling repartee. I can’t wait to catch up on all the past episodes!

The Carroll sisters provide a great new dynamic to crime podcast. Uncanny, and creepy. This podcast has the right mixture to make your ears twitch. Part Advice column and part stories is an amazing concept and the girls deliver. LiSTEN NOW!

I love the combination of horror and advice column that is Dear Murder Street. These sisters have a wonderfully spooky podcast!

Talk only siblings can share with a great hook. Very easy listening and good getting to know our hosts who put a lot of themselves into their work, and it shows and benefits them greatly.

I love the dynamic between the ladies. So funny and interesting! #LadyPodSquad

This podcast is fun and very interesting. The ladies kept me on my toes and I am sad that I am all caught up and have to wait for new episodes! I love the stories and the banter! Amy 10-96 Crime Chicks Podcast

Awesome podcast, very enjoyable and easy to listen to. Kept me on my toes!

The Dear Murder Street Podcast is one of the rare gems you're always looking for but can never seem to find. With expert audio quality, a fantastic premise, and great conversation, this wholly original Podcast will leave you longing for more. Stop reading my review and hit play already!