The giants passed on Joe Milton in the draft for a reason, right? But Now, after seeing him play ONE GAME against the bills back ups who had essentially nothing to play for , these guys are all set to give up a THIRD ROUND PICK (conditional, sure .. but still) for him. Give me a break. And then Jerry of course “ omg Chris that’s awesome that’s the best thing I ever heard” . Please chill . Maybe a later round pick or something but let’s stop being crazy. I love the show but some of the takes are just too much

I listen to every episode. Jerry and Chris both do a great job providing a fan perspective and some inside the building information from a long time Giants beat writer. I’ll never forget Chris discussing the Giants/Lions scrimmage in the 2023 pre season. I heard him say the Giants were surprised at the level of practice intensity of the Lions. Look at the trajectory of the two teams since those scrimmages. Those kind of observations and insights are why I listen. It’s been a rough decade plus for Giants fans but a lot of us still follow the team 365 days a year. Whether I agree with them or not on how the Giants should move forward I appreciate their opinions and analysis. It keeps me engaged. The Giants should thank them.

Best pod out there. Must listen!

5 Stars

Realistic take on a pretty woeful franchise over the last decade …

So so podcast some bad some good Podcaster deleted me on X for being too negative a while back What have Giants done not to deserve that? Being honest

These two are absolute cringe to listen to.. between Bisignano’s constant hate on others to Jerry Foley’s wishy washy butt kissing of Bis. And that new theme music they’ve added, OMG it’s like two old guys trying to be hip! Save yourself the time and listen to a better podcast.

Everyone needs a Jerry in their life, best hype man this side of the Mississippi.

Great show. I wish it was a daily show because I want more whenever the show ends but I get it, They’re busy guys. Go Giants!

Sy was great loved hearing his review. The more I listen to the podcast the more I think Chris doesn’t like Jerry. He cuts him off and doesn’t let him get questions in. Jerry is great, but I don’t think Chris wants him on the pod.

Consistently great content, the playoff interview with Lawrence Tynes was over the top interesting.

Love the show, Chris’s inside and Jerry fandom an awesome listen! Go Giants!

The hands down best Giants podcast out there. They say what we all think as “intelligent” Giants fans. Would love to run into them at training camp or a tailgate. Keep up the good work.

You guys the taken being the “realistic fans” too far. Chris really believes he’s like a football god, and repeats himself constantly! It’s hard to be happy listening to this pod. How often do you have to say the Titans are better then us? Also Jerry please stop saying “good job by you” and “good stuff”. I used to consider myself a member of the buffoon crew. Then you guys took away the best part of the show. “Buffoon of the week”. Also you guys did Patricia Traina dirty. She help Chris get a little notoriety, and y’all never returned the favor.

Jerry and Chris are the best in providing NY Giants insight and interviews!.

This is the best Giants podcast in the business. Not sure what else needs to be said. Chris’ insider knowledge of the team certainly adds a dimension to this podcast that all others lack. But for Christs sake it’s Eh-zoo-doo, not Eh-zee-dee-oo

You two buffoons are the Best. I really enjoy your podcast, especially during draft season; the Syversten and Serritella podcast were OUTSTANDING!!! I can’t thank you two enough for all the great Giant Insider info you two put out. From an ancient buffoon to you two young buffoons, keep up the GREAT Work; I wish you guys all the best!!! Go Big Blue Johnny T P.S. Chris, that story about the guy in the truck you thought might want to whack you… friggin hilarious; I was waiting for you to say it was some disgruntled dude you hustled on the golf course… rofl🫡👊🫡

Really enjoyed the Giant Insider up until a year ago. Once Chris fell for Wesley Steinberg’s tweet about Kelvin Benjamin stealing food, the show went down hill. It’s hard to look past Chris believing the parody account and later pretending to know it was fake by replying “gotcha! to several twitter users when called out. I’ll never forget the line tweeted by Chris, “You can’t make this up” when first reporting what “he was hearing”. 🤣 It’s ok to be wrong and to fall victim to false reporting. Just admit it and stop blocking your critics. It’s cowardly to block your critics and delete tweets. Please tone down the Red Sox and Rangers discussions on the podcast and twitter feed, we’re here for the Giants. Lastly, please take the time to properly pronounce the players names. You guys are pretty bad with this. Despite my criticisms, you guys get a 3/5 stars. One of the better Giants podcasts out there, maybe try to engage better with the younger fan base.

Stick to football Chris. Your arguments don’t cut it as far as the Red Sox and the Devils go. Enough Ranger and Yankee bashing please.

He just said “…in the middle rounds Gettleman couldn’t pick his nose if it had a 40 foot booger!” I was driving and had to pull over. Too funny!!.

Do you hear anything about 6’7” 275 lb Jelani Woods? On radar for giants???

Chris and Jerry are fans that talk like fans but have the access to the team because they work in the field. This Pad is a must listen to during the season and the off-season.

When they complained about decisions they praised after seeing the results is when the lost me.

I will for the life of me not understand how these dudes have a media pass. He acts like he has the inside scoop. You can get everything just from the giants app. zero respect at all.

These guys are the best. Plugged in and no nonsense. Tune in for your weekly dose of therapy. Darth Durango

There was no reason to hate on Yankee fans on your (10/6) podcast. We all get emotional about the teams we follow. Choosing the day after our season suddenly ended to accuse us of being front runners and then circling back to take a shot at our broadcaster? There is such a thing as kicking someone when they are down. It’s considered low class.

Been listening to this podcast for a while now. I love how big of fans they are but also keep it real with their analysis ! Keep it up fellas. A buffoon for life!

I am a huge Giants fan and came across this podcast these two guys are amazing and tell it how it is no sugarcoating on this show that’s what sets this shall apart love the atmosphere the energy that the guys put on and all the information that they provide I would strongly recommend any Giants fan to follow this podcast it’s hard not to miss a shell it’s always interesting waiting to see what topics come up. Love the show keep up the amazing work 🏈🏈🏈💪🏽💪🏽

Top 3 Giants pod for me. Funny and insightful, from a true fan’s perspective.

These guys report tweets of others as their own sources. Even parody accounts. They then talk like what they say are facts. They are mostly wrong and the show is just terrible. When they try to break down film, it is laughable. I can’t believe people pay for what they put out.

Chris steals scoops from a parody account and then lies about it. Joe Judge gave every single beat reporter a one on one interview except Chris because he’s a blogger with a press pass.

Really happy to say that since having people call into the show this pod seems to have taken an upswing towards some really quality content. Thanks guys, good work!

Chris is the star, very knowledgeable And love the accent. Seems to have an in with the Giants. Jerry is good, but just not up on things like Chris. Sometimes Jerry deserves to be slapped. But I still love listening to you both. Keep it up.

Love Bobby and Justin. Keep it up guys. Talkin Giants v the world. Simple man radio great as well.

I’m not one to review podcasts, but I had to let you know that I enjoy yours very much. Your interviews with X Giants like Mark Bavaro are amazing, and I truly look forward to listening to your show every week. Thank you!

For someone, Mark Bavaro, who appeared to be a quiet giant during his playing days, he made for a great interview. Great job. Just FYI, every time Chris was speaking, there was feedback or an echo. Otherwise it was an excellent listen. Thanks guys.

It’s ok, basic, but there are better options for news, game and player evaluation. Jerry drools over everything Chris says like a school girl. Chris thinks his S doesn’t stink and has all the inside news but doesn’t. Chris does actually knows the game, but they don’t talk about it on the pod. It’s a beat writer and homer giving basic info, nothing more.

Absolutely LOVING the Giant Greats you are interviewing. These are the best podcasts you have done! Keep them coming!!!

Simply the best. It’s not over the top with “X”s and “O”s stuff. Straight forward, no bias, no hype. Just two Giant fans talking. Well worth it!!!

Love the podcast and their enthusiasm for Giants football. Very knowledgeable hosts who give a more in-depth take than the national and local media. NFL draft debate - I don’t understand the love affair with Kyle Pitts. In the last decade plus, the NFL have been dominated by Tight Ends that were NOT drafted in the first round (Kittle, Kelce, Ertz, Gronk, Graham, Witten) and have been littered with first rd flame outs (Keller, pettigrew, gresham, eifert, ebron, Howard, engram!, njoku). That’s 34 pro bowls and 11 all pros vs 5 pro bowls and 0 all pros! We just got burned by Evan Engram and history proves that you are more likely to find a quality TE later in the draft vs the top. Why waste a valuable pick on Kyle pitts when we get a TE in the 2nd or 3rd, red shirt him for a season, and then slide him into the starting lineup the following year when we let Engram walk as a free agent? Excited to hear your take.

Been listening to this podcast for almost 2 years now. Must listen to for every Giants fan that wants analysis from an objective, knowledgable, and passionate fan duo who also work to cover the team as members of the media! Chris and Jerry are very critical of the team when necessary but yet also bring the excitement that all Giants fans feel after a good performance!

Good podcast but wish you guys would be more consistent with your criticism. You got a group of Giants having drinks after a brutal loss, you got two faces of the franchise two captains and the best you can say it’s “they are kids” ? But I constantly hear u guys attack Odell over and over. you got a video of Barkley on a dame bike with a torn ACL but that didn’t even get mentioned. Come one guys just be consistent

Two very likable guys who combine a fan’s outlook with real X’s and O’s knowledge and “insider” information. Excellent stuff.

Good overall podcast and good insight. Would be a 5 with some minor improvements: 1) Being prepared with fan questions in advance and ready to go and 2) with preparation podcasts would be shorter with same content. May sounds like nitpicking but that’s the difference between GI and 5 star podcasts I listen to. But this is very good overall and my favorite Giants podcast and I like there fandom. Just could do with less listening of Jerry hunting and pecking through twitter looking for Qs. Recommend it but waiting for their producer to take them to the next level.

Chris is very unprofessional both on twitter and his repeated ”do you understand what I'm saying?” 50 times per episode.

Sorry I disagree will Hill he needs to get more snaps which it will be hard for him unless Leonard,Lawrence and Tomlinson get hurt.

Best in the game. Inside info, no homer attitude, straight forward. Need more than once a week ;)

Guys, Great work. I’m a die hard Giants fan living in the ATL. Your pod got me thru the first half of 2020. Keep up the great work.

Love the podcast, always fair and honest. New York media tends to be overly critical and always trying to stir controversy or be overly negative, while team employed media can at times be bias and paint everything out to always be perfect. These two are very balanced, give credit and criticism as honestly and fairly as can be. Entertaining to listen to and always great feedback and communication with fans & listeners. First rate all around.

Chris and Jerry do a great job covering the Giants! They have great insight and perspective! Look forward to hearing the next episode!