The set up of these episodes take way too long to get to the point… I appreciate context but what is detailed is not pivotal to the stories. The side conversations just make em fast forward.

It seems like it’s hard for the hosts to stay on topic which is frustrating for me as the listener. I almost wonder if they are just trying to fill time…also maybe they should be recording at a different time if the f’ing ice cream truck comes by everyday at the same time.

Love the show guys it’s amazing and I look forward to 👂🏽each week! Correct me if I’m wrong but I don’t believe you guys have done a show on Robert Pickton aka Willie Pickton yet YIKES talk about sinister! 😳love you guys keep up the great work! 💕

Being a long time fan of all things creepy I thought I had heard most of these cases, but holy $h!t I’ve had the most fun listening to sylas & stew dissect them! It’s like listening to your bff at band camp (in the best way). They give the stories i thought id for sure everything about a whole new feel and perspective ! Now ive sent to all my creepy friends & am guilty of busting out a southern accent on occasion ❤️

I am a podcast junkie and subscribe to so many podcasts. I listen for six to nine hours a day. My favorite hosts hands down! They are intelligent, insightful ,respectful and funny like a friend. Most of the cases they cover, I’ve heard on other podcasts. The level of research done on every episode is incredible. There is always information that is new to me, every single case. They take you through each episodes in a way that makes you feel as though you are sitting with them going through everything. They go through and lay out different theories evidence etc. in a way that makes you think long after you’ve listened and they don’t push their opinions.

Absolutely LOVE the stories, and what the podcast is supposed to be. However, I can’t stand (and often times toward) the long side conversations they have. Even through some of the episodes they’ll make comments about how “I’m sure the creepers are saying hurrying up and go to the next story). I literally find myself saying that very thing be quite and start the next story. Again the. Podcast itself (stories are great). I just wish they wouldn’t talk so much in between stories and while telling them.

I like the content but for a while I thought it was playing in fast forward. He just speaks very fast.

I love u guys so much I literally get chills down my spine just listening to the episodes thanks so much for making these episodes ❤️❤️❤️

the juxtaposition between the unfortunate true stories being told and the personalities between both sylas and stew make this one of the most interesting and entertaining podcasts i’ve listened to, give it a listen PLEASE

I wait every week to listen to my pals. Yes, they feel like my actual friends. The way Sylas tells the story is like he's just a friend, chatting. And Stew is so engaging. And has great insights. Their chemistry is so great and so inviting. Come on in and listen to this crazy tale--that's how it feels. Just fantastic storytelling. My absolute fave podcast.

That is a statement. My friend and I were on a field trip and she played it for me and now I’m obsessed! It has great stories and the hosts have a great sense of humor. I will never stop listening to this podcast. 10/10 would definitely recommend!

I just wanted to let Silas and Stew know how much I love this show! So happy I became a Premium Creeper so I can enjoy the extra episodes. Listening to your show feels like hanging out with friends. Keep up the awesome work. Love you guys!!

I love this podcast, can’t get enough! The banter is great too, adds levity and keeps me company while I bop around neighborhoods delivering mail 🤩🥳

You guys are the absolute best, I am literally obsessed with Sylas, Stu and CreepTime!!! I recommend you to all of friends! So much love from Central Virginia!

I love listening to you guys! I enjoy the banter when I’m commuting. It makes the drive tolerable. No matter how silly I feel when I’m laughing alone in my car.

I really wanted to love this podcast because my friend told me about it, but you just do too much talking amongst each other and not enough research, getting things mixed up.

I love the chemistry between Sylas and Stew but if I hear the word “insidious” one more time I will snap. It makes my teeth hurt every time Sylas says it, which is on average 15-20 times each episode. Please, please, please…..EXPAND YOUR VOCABULARY 🙄

Recently discovered this podcast! Been bingeing the heck out it while I’m at work! Love it! You guys can entertain me for 10 hour shift and I love it. Y’all are so cute and I just love you both

Listening to a looot of crime podcasts out there but this one pulls me in! Like the vibe between stew and sylas what makes it easy to listen and then so good information on the cases! Glad I found it!!

Just in time!!!!!

I have never been into poscasts. I gave this one a try because I LOVE murder mysteries and supernatural spooky stuff. And to say I have been OBSESSED is an absolute UNDERSTATEMENT!!! I have been binging this for a week straight and I’m already 40 episodes in. 😅 I can now say that I’m a podcast girly. I love the chemistry and laid back vibe that is Creeptime. 🖤

Love the chemistry and friendship that to the two hosts have! They are hilarious but also so well researched and informed about the cases and deliver the stories in a great way. Love you guys thanks for all the content!

Baby, I love you both! You are funny and fabulous and your research is on point! Also love your chemistry not phony or forced at all. Just one caveat: Silas please look up the definition of read herring, you aren’t using it properly. Keep up the amazing podcast and no shade here!

Absolutely love the banter but more research def needs to be done. It drives me insane when they mix up facts of well-known cases. Love yall though

I really wanted to like this podcast because they have covered some of the cases I’m most interested in. But the off topic banter sets my teeth on edge.

I just found this podcast and I’ve been binging! Also Stew has one of the best laughs I ever heard.

Drives me crazy when they don’t know details/ important storyline stuff. Used to love this podcast but whenever I hear a version they cover of a story I already know, there are soo many mixups and forgotten details. I know it’s for fun but more research pretty please! 🙏

I was always a Morbid weirdo, still am, but they have been doing such old outdated cases I got bored and looked for something else. Listening to Silas and Stew it wonderful on my long commutes. The episodes are perfect length, and they complement each other entirely. I love their banter. I feel like they’re my friends telling me a story. I love that their cases are modern and relatable. They really draw their audience in. Amazing podcast guys, love being a creeper too💜

Their banter is so excellent and I love how they aren’t afraid to discuss the most horrific crimes out there but still keep it hilarious. Sylas’ dedication, vocabulary and storytelling is so enthralling and Stew is adorable and such a good counter to Sylas! I just binged the whole show and I am so sad there aren’t more episodes!

I love y’all’s banter it helps keep the scary from being too scary the way both of y’all can tell each story and engage is very interesting. Each one keeps me coming back for more and it’s made me more paranoid I will say but in a good way. I was never into house wife’s or most of the shows y’all talk about but hearing y’all talk about that or just anything in general I love so much it’s extremely funny. I listen during work which I’m not supposed so I have to try so hard not to smile or bust out laughing. I just started listening to after dark too and Madame Ham making it qeek had me literally dying I had to hide my face so I could laugh because I couldn’t hold it in. Please keep this and all y’all’s other podcasts going I love it and I love y’all so much 10/10 would listen to always again! ❤️❤️❤️

You guys are so entertaining and Sylas is the best story teller. Love the cases you share!

Let me just say you both are AMAZING!!! I just finished episodes 50 (I know I’m behind lol) and let me just say I LOVE your whole podcast but episode 50 AMAZING research!! I have never knew much about the Ramsey case and wow mind blown!! Anyways I love love LOVE you both keep up the amazing work!!

the way sylas gets part way through the top line and then i get asked if i want to make a podcast 😂 makes me laugh every time. the only way i could describe this podcast is that it’s a rollercoaster, it’s wild. This is the only podcast that actually spooks me to my core because the storytelling is THAT good, it turns into a movie in my head. anyway, it’s so good and i can’t stop binge listening to all of the episodes 😩

Of course I listen on Spotify and am reviewing on Apple, I’m a creeptime the podcast listener! On a more serious note though, this podcast is the best podcast I’ve ever listen to. At first the banter bothered me, but you just have to get through a couple of episodes and you are HOOKED. Even though I have absolutely nothing in common with Sylas and Stew, and have no idea what or who they’re talking about most of the time, they are hilarious and I find myself laughing out loud through the episodes. Both of their storytelling skills are unmatched! They’re both such natural storytellers and live such interesting lives aside from their talented podcast hosting. They’re reactions are dramatic, but it’s honestly true to who they are and it makes for good entertainment. You know they respect the stories and they see the victims as real people with real lives and not just stories to be retold. Take this review as a sign to start listening! I recently became a premium sub because I couldn’t get enough of their amazing content! Love you guys, keep up the good work and I wish you all the best in life! 🫶🏼

Love that they aren’t afraid to dig into to gory and dirty details. Being a crime podcast fan for years you can tell they are wet behind the ears and I can’t tell if Stu is high, doesn’t like true crime, or is just nervous bc it seems like she isn’t listening half of the time .

Silas and Stew make me feeling like I’m listening to my own conversations I have with my best friend. I actually enjoy the side stories, they’re hilarious. A genuine element of levity exists in every episode so I feel it’s well balanced. Tbh I’ve already heard about the stories covered on other podcasts, but I love Silas’ take on them and Stew’s keen assessment of the cases and expansion on the theories.

Good podcast for certain episodes, tell the story please stop interjecting with personal stories for long periods of time.

Y’all I just have to say if you have not listened to creeptime yet you’re missing out. I’m beyond obsessed and have listened to every episode (even the premiums). The banter is unmatched and the story telling of every case is amazing I’m always hooked right from the beginning. I freaking love Sylas and Stew, please keep up the amazing work 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼

I love y’all’s banter. I listen to all the creep time pods because listening to you guys is like chatting with friends. Please never stop or change!

This is one of my new favorite podcasts!! I look forward to the new episodes and hearing all the great cases and stories Sylas & Stew cover. I couldn’t get enough so I had to bump myself to premium 💗

Loving this one - so many interesting episodes and the hosts do an excellent job!! I like how they flow together.

I really like how you guys deep dive into the story and give lots of details. I was searching for the case of the girls who were lost in Panama and stumbled on this podcast. I have listened to several different podcasters tell this story and this one by far has the most details. Love the voices telling the stories. I will definitely continue to listen and will add them to my list!

I literally downloaded Apple Podcasts just to get more of Creeptime. You two seriously are the best. The humor, the commentary, and the preparation and work that goes into each and every episode is so very appreciated. Thank you both SO much for all you both do! - can’t trust county

Legit just heard my first 2 episodes and I love them already. Can’t wait to hear all of them!!!

Sylas has an amazing voice, stew has great commentary. I love the community they built. After dark is amazing, fun way to feel like you know them even more. The Sinister does kind of feel like a 20 minute add with blips of a story sprinkled in. BUT we can’t all be perfect, the podcast and brand as a whole is really amazing. 10/10 new go to fav.

i truly wish silas and stew were my friends in real life. this podcast is what gets me through my work day. every single day. i’ve never listened to a podcast where i audibly crack up laughing with the hosts until now. please don’t stop the banter, your stories are so funny. i mean this from the bottom of my heart, i love you guys 🥹

This is the only podcast I’ve ever stuck with. Love the chitchat between Silas and Stew. I could listen to them talk about any subject. The episodes are both interesting and amusing. Please consider covering the 2013 disappearance of Jessica Heeringa!

I waited till I was avke to become a premium member, and I’m currently caught up on creep time and going though the premium episodes now. Snd honestly Sylas and Stew are amazing at telling the stories, Sylas be having me on the Edge of my seat while Stew and I ask the hard questions. I’ve learned so many things on this podcast and the entertainment is top-notch, if your looking for a podcast on true crime and weird cases this is it. Also don’t trust county. Ps. Sylas is also sponsored by Spotify with the be notification. “Allegedly”

idk where to begin! i believe i was introduced to you guys on tiktok and then started binge listening to every episode on apple and haven’t stopped since. i am now apart of the premium episodes, after dark, sinister and the reddit blog and i can’t thank you, syals & stew for making me feel apart of a great friendship that i haven’t had in a while. i always listen to the pod while i get ready for work, AT WORK and just at home cleaning. ANY CHANCE i get i listen lol, ill even replay episodes when ive ran out because i love you guys that much! you guys have also inspired me to create a little pod of my own, haven’t gotten it off the ground but it’s still a very prominent idea. i just wanna thank you so much for making Creeptime the Podcast, i love this community you have built off your podcast, it is beautiful and i cherish every bit of it 🤍

I’ve had this show on my roster for a while but just started listening regularly recently. The hosts are super awesome and so funny and tell the stories in an incredible way. I knew I would be a long time listener going forward when I heard the raving about Aldi. This girl LOVES Aldi. I bleed the Aldi color palette. I shame buy the new weekly items like they’re going out of business. I clean my junk pile of a vehicle just to have room to fit all my (reusable, YES!) bags. Anyway, enough about Aldi (for now lol). Highly recommend this show and I will be mindlessly listening while doing my no point mundane tasks at work from now on. Thank you to the hosts for all the hard work that goes into research and producing this show🫶