Recent Episodes
-
Detecting a Murderer
May 26, 2025 – 00:21:57 -
Terror in the Woods
May 12, 2025 – 00:24:01 -
The Beast of British Columbia
Apr 28, 2025 – 00:27:52 -
The Return (UPDATE)
Apr 21, 2025 – 00:09:11 -
High Strangeness
May 13, 2024 – 00:27:45 -
Secret Tunnels Beneath Us (Part 2)
Apr 29, 2024 – 00:38:08 -
A Stalker's Obsession
Apr 15, 2024 – 00:21:32 -
Escape from the Creature in the Night
Apr 1, 2024 – 00:23:34 -
The Bag Man
Mar 18, 2024 – 00:20:43 -
Roommate Homicide
Mar 4, 2024 – 00:40:08 -
Mystery at Swauger Lake
Feb 19, 2024 – 00:25:04 -
The Intruder
Feb 5, 2024 – 00:19:45 -
Secret Tunnels Beneath Us (Part 1)
Jan 22, 2024 – 00:46:52 -
Bloodshed on the Buffalo National River
Jan 8, 2024 – 00:20:30 -
Shadow People (Holiday Special)
Dec 25, 2023 – 00:11:35 -
The 100 Foot Fall
Dec 11, 2023 – 00:30:13 -
I'm Back (UPDATE)
Dec 4, 2023 – 00:03:33 -
Why I'm Taking A Break From The Podcast (UPDATE)
May 12, 2023 – 00:03:29 -
Phantom in the Night
May 8, 2023 – 00:19:26 -
UNNERVED BANTER: Pilot Sucked out of Plane (Flight 5390) + Do UFO and Bigfoot Sightings Mean Anything?
May 1, 2023 – 00:30:36 -
Trailer: UNNERVED - True Scary Stories
Apr 24, 2023 – 00:01:29 -
Road Rage Shooting
Apr 17, 2023 – 00:14:52 -
UNNERVED BANTER: "Worst Case Scenario" Survival Game
Apr 10, 2023 – 00:26:55 -
Date Gone Wrong
Apr 3, 2023 – 00:25:17 -
BONUS: Update + Interview With Dr. J. Allen Hynek
Mar 27, 2023 – 01:30:03 -
UNNERVED BANTER: The Traveling Corpse (Elmer McCurdy) + The Bloop Heard Round the World
Mar 20, 2023 – 00:34:33 -
Attacked by Hippo
Mar 13, 2023 – 00:34:10 -
UNNERVED BANTER: The Radium Girls + The Disappearance of the Sodder Children
Mar 6, 2023 – 00:43:22 -
Body in the Water
Feb 27, 2023 – 00:21:01 -
UNNERVED BANTER: The Woman Who Birthed Rabbits (Mary Toft) + A Pig's Dark Side
Feb 20, 2023 – 00:36:22 -
Bigfoot Encounter at The Boundary Waters
Feb 13, 2023 – 00:31:16 -
UNNERVED BANTER: The Dancing Plague of 1518 + Coincidental Twin Tragedy in Bermuda
Feb 6, 2023 – 00:45:14 -
Chased by UFO
Jan 30, 2023 – 00:27:43 -
UNNERVED BANTER: The Somerton Man + Seal Attacks in South Africa
Jan 23, 2023 – 00:42:00 -
The Hammer Killer
Jan 16, 2023 – 00:28:36 -
UNNERVED BANTER: Buried Alive (Octavia Hatcher) + Human Heart Found in a Salt Pile
Jan 9, 2023 – 00:38:41 -
Horror in the Pine Barrens
Jan 2, 2023 – 00:23:05 -
Terror on Campus
Dec 12, 2022 – 00:19:40 -
Hitchhiker Turned Murderer
Nov 28, 2022 – 00:15:54 -
The Creature From Sweet Hollow Road
Nov 14, 2022 – 00:16:55 -
Grandma's UFO Encounter
Oct 31, 2022 – 00:29:05
Recent Reviews
-
MadiganGrrlTrue and creepyThis is so great, real people telling their own stories and if there is any kind of sources to back them up, you’ll hear that too. Thanks Chris, for your work.
-
ackurFans of Radio Rental and Let’s Not Meet will love this podcast!If you like the podcasts Let’s Not Meet and Radio Rental, but with better editing and historic/social knowledge dropped in there too, this is it!
-
ThatDudeDevNiceI found you in the Radio Rental subreddit and I’m glad that I did, because this podcast is good. I like when people tell their own stories. It would be cool if you sent them a recording kit for them to to tell their stories on if they don’t have a mic, so that the audio quality is better, but I love this podcast so far regardless. Keep it up! *Please come back! Radio Rental is awful now! It’s anyone’s game! I swear I’ve heard better ghost stories on Nickelodeon than RR could ever churn out.
-
Sfelice80Great Podcast!!I came across a Reddit rec for your podcast and I binged it all in a week! I’m always on the hunt for firsthand stories told by the experiencer and this does not disappoint. I hope there’s more to come😁
-
Greta22GirlLove it!I was recommended this show by a family member and I’ve been obsessed! As someone who is a big fan of Radio Rental, I find Unnerved to be right up my alley. The stories are very interesting and the structure of the episodes are easy to follow. I enjoy that the stories are told by those who experienced them and that there are follow up interview questions to add more information about their experiences.
-
albaby70Great show!The stories are interesting and I love the personal stories told from the people who experienced them.
-
Pim KangAmazing podcastLike the other review mentioned, I also found this podcast on Radio Rental subreddit. I am so glad someone suggested this podcast because it’s amazing stories well told, well produced. Thank you for your hard work!
-
Shadow Broker18Very goodLove the sound design. Very “Creep Show”/1980’s vibes. Original true stories! What more can you ask for?
-
AmyinautumnLOVEYou’re awesome! Thank you for creating these episodes! They keep me entertained on my drive! How can someone submit a story though??
-
guy461Superb start!!This podcast is an incredible addition to the very few first person reports of strange or frightening experiences that are shared on pods. Just truly well done, almost perfect editing, and a gem in the podcast world of this genera. Thank you so much!
-
JUtah31I like itIt’s entertaining and the delivery and editing are good. I’m a little skeptical of the Buffalo River shooting episode though. They were swimming in a river in December? The guy had a handgun in the back of his shorts as he sat in an inner tube in the river? Nevertheless, it’s an entertaining podcast.
-
lbeard501Fascinating strange stories - Must listen!Unnerved was recommended to me since I also listen to Radio Rental, and Unnerved is now a favorite. I binged all of it in one day! Chris is a natural & engaging storyteller, and the story topics are so odd and gripping. I also love the conversations & storytelling between him and Jeremiah during Banter episodes. Give this a listen, folks!!
-
JessMcCannGREAT!Update!! He’s back! Yay! So excited to hear the new episodes! Welcome back 💕 Just found this podcast and I’m about to binge it, love stories told in first person, especially creepy ones. First episode was well done, can’t wait I listen to more!
-
JellyyjaamLove this pod!Host does a good of setting the mood and the stories are really great. My new favorite pod!
-
KatizinhaA mix of all my favorite thingsThis podcast is like a conglomeration of all of my favorite scary story telling podcasts. The production is really solid, the stories and their tellers are all captivating, and I love the addition of supporting documentation of similar events. I enjoy Chris as a host, he really highlights the story teller and supports the story as much as possible. Not to mention, the intro is so nostalgic and awesome and I really can’t see what else will come from this Podcast.
-
AimerzkNew favorite pod!I’m really impressed by this podcast and am so glad to have found it! It reminds me a bit of Radio Rental! Keep it up!
-
greenmelamineChilling, but in a fun way.I’ve been thoroughly enjoying listening over the past few weeks. I like to satisfy that need for rather spooky stories without feeling truly disturbed, and this fits that niche for me. Still, when I’m in the workout room listening to this by myself it keeps me on my toes haha. Although he hits some classic spooky topics hit on by other podcasts, he’s come up with stories I’ve never heard, not to mention there’s something compelling about stories of everyday people in wild situations. They’re stories you won’t really find anywhere else in those cases.
-
alittlebitangieMore true crime? YES PLS! 👻Looking forward to checking out more episodes of this show. I am especially intrigued by UFOs and murder mysteries, so I can tell this will be right up my alley!
-
faintlyvisibleUnnerving!I am definitely unnerved after listening to this podcast! Chris does a great job of presenting these creepy stories through first-person accounts and atmospheric music and sound effects. Add this one to your rotation and listen with the lights on!
-
Mxsandy12Creepy and wonderful!Love it!!!!
-
HhhhiCompelling stories and well producedWell worth your time host does a great job and it's super interesting and unique hearing the stories directly from the source! Keep up the good work!
-
Starlord35InterestingI really enjoy the intro music. Wish the episodes were longer as I listen to them while I work.
Similar Podcasts

Disturbed: True Horror Stories

Unexplained Encounters

Otis Jiry's Scary Stories Told in the Dark: A Horror Anthology Series

You Can See Me in the Dark

Scary Story Podcast

Scary Stories & Rain

Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep

Chilling True Tales - True Ghost and Paranormal Stories

Horror Story: Ghosts, Mysteries, and Hauntings

Just Creepy: Scary Stories

True Scary Story

Scary | A Paranormal Podcast

The Whispering Woods - Real Life Ghost Stories

My Paranormal Experience

Tell Me A Ghost Story
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork on this page are property of the podcast owner, and not endorsed by UP.audio.