Hallmark Mysteries & More

Hallmark Mysteries and More is the ultimate destination for Sleuthers and fans of Hallmark's beloved mystery genre. Hosts Andrea and Eric bring their extensive knowledge and passion to every episode, offering insightful reviews and analysis of both current releases and classic favorites. 

As the only podcast dedicated exclusively to this cherished corner of Hallmark programming, we dig deep into the themes, characters, and storytelling that make these mysteries so special.

Beyond our comprehensive reviews, we regularly welcome interviews with Hallmark's biggest stars, directors, writers, and production team members, giving Sleuthers unprecedented behind-the-scenes access. Our conversational style balances fun, engaging banter with informative content that both casual viewers and dedicated Hallmark mystery enthusiasts will appreciate.

Whether you're a longtime Sleuther or just discovering the charm of Hallmark mysteries, join Andrea and Eric for entertaining discussions that celebrate and explore this unique genre. Subscribe now for your weekly dose of mystery, community, and all things Hallmark!

Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @hallmarkmysteriesandmore 

**This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel. **

Recent Episodes

Episodes loading...

Recent Reviews

JPRainbiw

Meh

I’m not sure why this podcast is covering the way home if they don’t really know what is going on in the episodes. If your going to review a show and give your opinion it’s probably a good idea to have some sort of clue what your talking about. There are thousands of fans truly invested in this show that probably listen to this and shake their head. Don’t recommend. There are others covering this show that know it well and do a great job of reviewing it and truly enjoy it.
LindaYogaGirl

Brand

New to Hallmark and really enjoying this podcast! Cozy mystery lover branching out from Poirot, Columbo and Murder She Wrote. Thanks for the pod!
The Popcorn Vendor

Best Hallmark Podcast

This is a great listen. Eric and Andrea play well off each other. Its not just a review podcast. Great guests and interviews. Love it!
Ultimate Hallmark Fan

Great Podcast and Funny Hosts

Andrea and Eric are funny, knowledgable, and entertaining. They have gotten interviews with some of the biggest names and got them to reveal juicy info you couldn’t get elsewhere. There are a lot of Hallmark podcasts out there, but this one is the best since they only talk about Hallmark mysteries. I love the podcast! :-)
aclaassen21

Hallmark Mystery Fan

I love that this podcast focuses exclusively on the Hallmark mystery series. As a mystery fan this podcast hits on all the notes. I love the interviews with popular mystery actors, directors, and writers. Keep the fun, drinks & mysteries coming!
daziegurl

I’ll Drink To That! 🍸

I’m def more into the romance element of Hallmark, but Eric and Sydney’s podcast makes me WANT to watch some of those mysteries! They’re fun to listen to, and I like how they call out the stuff that may make zero sense…just because they love Hallmark doesn’t mean they see everything through those rose-colored glasses. I also love the wardrobe talk AND the cocktails! 🥂 to Eric and Sydney for creating a podcast that I look forward to listening to!
MerryMaker89

A Hallmark Sleuther’s Dream

I’m so glad that there is a podcast devoted to Hallmark Mysteries. I just started them in 2021, but this podcast is making me want to rewatch them all 🤗
Aiden Harmston

Fun new podcast

I’ve gotta say, after listening to almost all of their episodes up to now, that this is a FUN podcast team. They don’t take themselves too seriously, but they do take their Hallmark Mysteries seriously - and that’s just what I want! Keep it up you’re both doing a great job.
Jendot0904

Hallmark Mysteries Education 101

Grateful to Eric and Sydney for starting this podcast and educating us all on the wonder that is Hallmark Mysteries movies! Excited to hear more! - Jennifer W
mkwrites2

Excited about this new podcast

Team Eric and Sydney are an entertaining duo. Their personalities shine through while keeping true to their format. They are both interesting people on their own, and they both have a skill for reviews. The banter is funny, their personal stories, engaging- It looks like the show will be a balance of interviews with interesting guests who provide behind-the-scenes tours into the production side but also reviews. Love the scoring system they worked out, and the cocktails. I’ll def be listening.
Jenny Roberts, Claire's mom

Excited for this Mystery Podcast!

I love following these two on IG and am thrilled they'll be deep diving Mystery Movies! I just started getting into all the Hallmark Mysteries so this is perfect timing 💙🙌
Person51129

Love the mystery focus!

Hallmark mysteries are the best, glad to see a podcast focus on them!
ReneeY.

Intro to Hallmark

If you’re like me, you always wondered about the allure of Hallmark but never took time to watch. Listening to a couple of experts dish on a mystery without being stuck to my couch - perfect! Great hosting and great content.
Catlady.89

Can’t wait!

Can’t wait to follow along with a cocktail! Love the banter, and looking forward to Sleuther style. Definitely and interesting take on Hallmark mysteries!