Carol Costello Presents: Blind Rage

In Season Two of her true crime series, The God Hook, journalist Carol Costello investigates the complex case of the Ohio Craigslist Killings—and in doing so, unearths the untold story of the crimes that preceded the murders—and the victims who’ve never received justice. Richard Beasley was convicted of murdering three men and attempting to kill a fourth in the fall of 2011, but before that heinous spree, authorities were building a human trafficking case against him. Now, working with the case's prosecutor, a county sheriff, and many closely involved sources, Carol examines previously unknown details of Beasley’s alleged crimes, and how he used the God Hook to lure his victims and bend them to his will.In Season One of this podcast, Blind Rage, journalist Carol Costello revisits the first big assignment she covered as a 22-year-old, novice reporter: Phyllis Cottles’ brutal attack. Psychologists call them “Triumphant Survivors,” but Phyllis Cottle was more than a survivor, she used this crime to better herself and the world around her. Support our show by becoming a premium member! https://evergreenpodcasts.supportingcast.fm

Recent Episodes

Episodes loading...

Recent Reviews

Matt_B_W

Stopped after 1 minute

It was immediately all about the hostess, which is a bad sign. Then there was a comment about it being a “man’s world” so I moved in.
CrockpotJones

Carol Costello Strikes Again

Already intrigued by where this story is headed. Can’t wait to see what they’ve uncovered.
sabs vibes

Outstanding

This is an excellent podcast, very nicely done, found myself sitting in my car didn’t want to miss a thing, Costello hit it out the park with the details! enjoyed.
GIGi CO

Very interesting

It was very interesting I really enjoyed the storyline the flow. You learned a little psychology it was very nicely done. Would recommend
Berbids

Oh wow

A remarkable woman and a remarkable true story. Very well told by Carol Costello. Must have been amazing to cover such a story as a novice reporter! Excellent job
DBelle1

Intriguing

The story was heroic and tragic. Glad it was brought to light
FallsNative

Very Good

I’m from Akron and remember this crime well. Ms. Costello did a nice job. I would like more access to the actual police, investigative, and prosecutorial reports/records and research used to produce this podcast. (your web link posts more about Ms. Costello than the crime.) Whatever happened to Ms. Cottle’s mother??
maleetree

Resilient Survivor

This story goes deep. It is well told and organized. There is a slight nod of racism, but unintentional, I believe. The survivor is strong. She makes this story so remarkable, What a beautiful human being. So much to learn from Phyllis, about life, death, and taking everything in between in stride and with grace. The ads were a bit much, but just skip through them. Also, the episodes are micro episodes at 20 min each but all episodes are available now so that wasn’t an issue for me.
lindsaysmith09

Lost me at the jungle comment.

I know what Reagan meant? Wow.
mike--san

Interesting Story. Could have been 2 episodes

20 minute segments are tedious. Too much non- story content including ads. All sorts of technical glitches like breath pop from microphones.
RK1438

Beyond Excellent !

When one combines tremendous research depth, unbiased reporting, and excellent storytelling, the result is Carol Costello’s Blind Rage. It doesn’t get better than this !!
Laura S. K.

Engaging, Insightful, and Riveting!

Bind Rage with Carol Costello is a standout among podcasts. Each episode is a deep dive into complex topics, presented with clarity and a well-structured format that keeps you hooked from start to finish. Carol's ability to engage with the subjects is impressive; she combines thorough research with a compelling narrative style that makes even the most intricate topics accessible and intriguing. Whether you're a long-time podcast enthusiast or a newcomer to the medium, Bind Rage offers a refreshing, educational, and utterly captivating journey. I highly recommend listening to it—you won't be disappointed!
CoCo Da Monkie

Too short

20. Minutes with advertisements included!? Yuck.
just trash this app

Disappointed

Love true crime and finding new and interesting podcasts. I believe this is the first one where I felt the host was intent on revealing her racism.
striwend

Poor Audio

The story on the podcast was amazing to hear. My only complaint is that the audio of original recordings was so poor that I found listening jarring at times. The recordings gave credibility to the story, so I understand why they used them. It was great to see that Carol Costello made the podcast. I loved starting my day with her on CNN. She presented a kind, friendly manner on and is my all-time favorite CNN anchor.
Okay I'm hooked

Mesmerizing Story

I could not wait until the next episode. Once you start you cannot wait for the next episode. What a great story of a very brave woman. You'll be amazed.
Ricky R Richard

Blind is the right word for this podcast

The host tries hard to drill a narrative which involves negative generalizations of folks she disagrees with… and they are the prejudiced ones?
Shaggy3001

Author is racist

Skip this one unless you love racism
ADW0805

Interesting story, bad delivery

Story is very interesting, but the reporting was just meh. And some episodes are 20 minutes. If it’s a weekly series, I want 30+ minutes an episode. I can’t imagine waiting a week for 20 minutes. Thankfully, I found this when all episodes were available.
krud1

Boring

Boring
gigitonae

Great reporting/Aweome/Story Teller

Phyllis’s story is crazy! Your telling this story is so well done. You are detailed, empathetic, angry for the victim and there is a sense that this resonated with you. I am caught up on my other shows and came across the is one. I’m so glad I did. I am an Ohio girl and this story put me right there with Phyllis. Thank you for your amazing work!
zrain777

Terrible reporting

The story could have been more interesting if it was a different reporter
Pawley I

This is awesome

Incredible story, extremely well done. Bring on your next project, Carol!
Turk4-4

Recounted with empathy and grace

I came across this podcast through an interview on One-to-One with John DeDakis. When the word “tragedy” isn’t big enough. Carol Costello, revisiting a gruesome assault she’d covered as a 22-year-old reporter, reintroduces us to Phyllis Cottle’s story almost 40 years later. Handled so skillfully in the telling, it gave me just enough time to breathe between episodes and grieve at the unlimited depths of our oddly human depravity. Costello gently and respectfully explores an impossibly difficult tale through the recollections and sentiments of many of those forever affected, including Phyllis—and Costello herself. Societal mirrors, like this, are the only way to know who we are, and who, with vigilance and care, we can be.
TimothyLaw

Gave Me Chills--and that's indeed a plural

Whoa…what a story. Goodness sake, to relive this as if it is happening before us is a moving experience. Carol Costello handles all this with deftness—she has an astounding set of details and pieces the crime and its aftermaths together with care and with a solid narrative structure. Binge material! And, as others have noticed, she gets right to the point. _Lots_ to unpack here. And to think that it indeed really all happened. Wow.
"mouse"

Thanks

Couldn’t have been any better written or told! I was on the edge of my seat the whole time! I’m so sorry that this victim and other victims suffer through insane brutality. We MUST keep the criminals in jail and stop letting them victimize others again and again. Thank you Carol Costello for keeping Phyllis’ story alive.
Dotsydo45

Blind Rage

Incredible storytelling and amazing protagonist - a true crime tale that beats them all! Excellent reporting by Carol Costello.
lpn1Butterfly

Love

This podcast is amazing and awesome. You did a great job telling us about this story. Carol Castello is amazing.
Bootyboots123

Good story, but too many dramatic Swooshes

The whooshing noise added for dramatic effect between interviews and varied moments is way over used and incredibly distracting. Less is more. Otherwise a well done podcast. But seriously, less drama swooshes, it detracts from the story telling.
MangoIsla

Love this podcast!

Carol Costello has a great voice to listen too. She explains things in detail but does not draw things out forever! Wonderful podcast! Great for true crime junkies. Can't wait for more 😃
Aec832002

Straight to the Point

I love this podcast it isn’t super long per episode and all drug out making it boring I am so hooked detailed and straight to the point just like I enjoy the crime stories!!!!
jlrlax

Episode 1

Wow! I’m hooked after the first episode.
bryan404

SUCH GREAT STORYTELLING

At just one episode in, I know this is going to be a special series. Carol has a wonderful ability to carefully tell a story - based in facts but with a human touch and compassion. Cannot wait for the entire series!!
charcharelliott

Love This

Can’t wait for next episode! Unbelievable story told by CNN news anchor Carol Costello! Tells the story of the strength and courage of an amazing lady. MUST LISTEN