I’ve been listening to Creepy for over a year now and loved it. Something changed though. A little before the 31 Days of Horror the stories just stopped being interesting. Then the 31 Days of Horror came along and that was extremely disappointing. Don’t get me wrong the production and the narrators are great but these stories are not it. I loved Creepy but it’s not worth listening to if maybe 1 of 4 stories per episode is good.

Great spooky stories. But it’s the narrator and his delivery that gives me chills!

You will not find anything like this podcast! It is absolutely beautiful. I highly suggest this to any horror lovers out there like I myself.

I loved the 31 days this year! Hoping you return to Creep-Away camp in January. Keep up the great work!

I love this and it doesn’t make you feel left out if you don’t fit in to some genres like other podcasts might. Plus he’s from Minnesota so that’s an extra star right there

This October’s Creepy has been my favorite! Great stories!! Keep up the great work.

I have been listening to creepy pod for about 6+ years. It was the first horror podcast I ever listen to, but this year I am really disappointed and 31 of horror 😔. Stories are hard to keep up with most other stories are narrated by one person. There hasn’t really been a story this month or the last month that I really enjoyed call put me on the edge of my seat. I will continue to support, but I would hope that the stories get better overtime. maybe John just needs some rest. Maybe let the older guy From the farm to narrate for a while or maybe there are some untold tales from the gas station.

Love the stories, can’t do the “Holders” episodes. Also can’t listen to JV Hampton-VanSant anymore, I skip right past as soon as I hear that monotone. 🤷‍♂️ Probably miss some good stories, but her voice doesn’t do any good story Justice.

I feel a great sense of pride being from the same state as the man who started it all, John Grilz. This is my favorite horror podcast of all time besides the magnus archives, the variety of the content and quality of the voice actors is unmatched. All that being said some of the hands down best episodes of all time are as follows: - Ted the caver - tales from the gas station - gods mouth - the sandman - necro sleep

The production quality is good, narrators are good. Some good episodes, but you have to go through 5 to get to 1. For the most part, the writing is not good.

Been listening for years. Always great voice acting and 95% of the stories are good

I feel a great sense of pride being from the same state as the man who started it all, John Grilz. This is my favorite horror podcast of all time besides the magnus archives, the variety of the content and quality of the voice actors is unmatched. All that being said some of the hands down best episodes of all time are as follows: - Ted the caver - tales from the gas station - gods mouth - the sandman - necro sleep

I am enjoying every minute and this radio station vibe is so wolfman Jack

I’ve been listening since 2019. I’ve enjoyed every bit of it, especially the classics such as, Ted the Caver, Tales from the gas station, 1999, and many others. Thank you John and crew!

Are we going to have to slog through the entire “Holders” series ? 500+ entries right ? Got old quick and isn’t getting any better. Creepy was better than this.

Man do I love this podcast. Tons and tons of stories highlighting how men are just awful, irredeemable, never-to-be-trusted abusers. There’s no room for the prospect that most men are a force for good who try to provide for their families and mind their own business…no sir! No in Creepy’s watch

I absolutely love the podcast, I’ve been listening for a few years now and I was at work and decided to start from the beginning again…. Omgggggg I love it it’s like I’m hearing some episodes for the first time lol again…..Megan McDuffee GIRL I love ur voice …. It’s so wispy and calming …. Even when the story is good and creepy you seem to just read wonderfully.. ok ok super fan girl over here the intro is awesome man just everything you guys do a wonderful job …. Alright bye lol and Thank you guys so much for the creeps 💯🫥 BTW I love the holder series…. I’d love to see how they come together…. Get it??? See what I did there lol ok ok fr this time bye ✌️

But like most shows they wanted as many people in their audience as possible. The result? Meandering stories that aren’t scary nor creepy, meant for children. Shame.

My favorite podcast by far!! Love it!!

I love this podcast! The Holders is the best!

Can’t give you less then 5 stars for half your stories, imagine how great it would be without the Holder Stories!

Thanks!

Uncle Henry is what brought me here. Holders are not holding me. Great show otherwise.

These voice actors are incredible, I have listened to all the free episodes. There is a massive variety of stories and writing styles. I see too many complaints about The Holder series, it’s temporary! I will say, I wasn’t into the series at first but it grew on me. Now I just really want to hear all of them to hear how it ends. I can’t skip episodes anyway. Hearing Jon start of each episode with the way he says “Nowww” just does something to me 🫢

I began listen about 2 years ago. My very first podcast EVER! I enjoyed so much. Couldn’t get enough. We were warned that the Holders stories aren’t fit everyone and it’s so true. They have no place here. I was never bored before but noticed I’ve skipped many episodes lately. Not sure where the problem lies but I know this podcast can definitely deliver.

Used to really enjoy listening to these episodes even like the first few “holders” episodes but have found myself skipping as soon as I hear the beginning of any of them. Still enjoy the other stories but the “holders” are just not it for me…

1st of all, there’s very few people in a RealEstate office that are paid ANY hourly wage. So there is no “Boss” to send you out anywhere.

Show went from great stories to SCP-style short “stories” giving “instructions” on how to find “Holders.” It’s incredibly boring, formulaic, and isn’t remotely scary. It really ruins my podcast experience to be listening to scary stories and suddenly some guy is telling me to go to the subway and spin around 5 times before knocking on a window 3 times and then shaking a dog’s paw exactly .947 times if I want to find the holder of bloody twinkies.

These stories are sooo creepy. Some are a bit disturbing, so depending on your age, you should listen to the listener discretion. This is for sure one of the best scary podcasts I have listened too! I LOVE the narrator! His voice is soooo good!! It’s a night and day difference from other podcasts I’ve listen too. Definitely give it a listen!!

I used to enjoy this show so much more when they stayed true to what made them successful. In the past year or so the stories just haven’t been scary or suspenseful. I think The Holders series really killed it for me, too slow and boring.

LOVE LOVE LOVE this podcast. It’s one of my favorite things to put on when I want some chills. I can’t get enough!

Love this show and series. John, don’t worry about the haters.

Never know what kind of story it’s gonna be, never know which superstar narrator is gonna pop up out of nowhere. But there’s always Jon, who’s narration is effortlessly solid, and every now and then he’ll hit a word with full frozen north accent and I laugh and laugh bc it’s great. Also the recent swamp episodes are fantastic. Swamp creepy is the creepiest creepy and y’all nailed it. Trust me, I’m Floridian. 🐊☀️🌴

I absolutely love Creepy! Creepaway Camp is fantastic!!!! Has a holiday (ie. Christmas) series ever been considered? I can only imagine how great it would be. Keep up the fantabulous work!!!!!

I wanted creepy stuff I got it I love it

If that’s cool with you This is your podcast

Always my go to bed time story! Rotation of narrators keeps things fresh. Can’t beat the annual extra spooky 31 days of Halloween. It also helps that my girlfriend is in love with two of the male narrators voices so she’s always more than willing to listen in on episodes! Great job Creepy!!

An earnest, well curated and acted scary/weird/gonzo story podcast that has mostly outgrown its “creepypasta” roots into a more mature weird fiction showcase. A variety of stories styles that are more hit than miss, and rarely pretentious even when occasionally overly ambitious. I still feel grateful I found this show on a cold dark lonely night years ago. It is a good listen by the fire. The host/creator is very likable.

Wish they curated the content a bit better. Many of the stories are great, but as often as not I find that I wish I had picked a different show.

Every holder’s episode is basically the same. I LOVE this podcast but every time time so dissatisfied it’s just another holder’s episode, please please take a break from therm. They’re so predictable and boring.

I used to really enjoy this podcast but The Holders series is such a pain to get through. I endured the first few episodes thinking that was it but we get more and more episodes. They’re so boring and they feel so repetitive. I haven’t listen to the last one but I can tell exactly what going to happen…

Mr. Creepy-pasta is a excellent narrator. Plain and simple. The story content well that leaves something to be desired. To all you writers out there, the woke traits more and more creepy pastas are having is getting absurd. You may find this shocking but not all or even most straight white males are actually pure evil. Crazy I know but I have been getting the sense that many of you don't know that since overwhelmingly the antagonists of stories are....straight white male (if the villain is human). Like all the time... Of course it is your complete right to write any story you wish but and some point you might have to display some creativity and find a new villain. And if you choose to write the same woke crap all the time people won't want to patronize you in any way. Crazy how that works huh?

definitely the best scary story podcast but also the favorite of all my podcasts (of which there are many, in several different genres). i look forward to it every Wed and Sun

I love this podcast! I enjoy most of the narrators, but I’ve started skipping any stories JV reads. They always sound sarcastic and condescending.

Just listen. Thank me later.

Love this podcast. Jon is the bomb!!

One day a religious person won’t be portrayed as a psychopath but not on this podcast.

You should really think about having more guest narration. I LOVE the show, the stories, but every time I hear the name of the narrator I can almost always know exactly how I’m going to feel about the story I’m going to hear. Mostly BORED. Honestly man. The only person that changes the tone or inflection of their character read is John. John is literally the only one that changes or even attempts something new ever. New accents, new changes of character. New ideas. I don’t know. I just know how I feel after two years of listening loyally.

I absolutely love this series and just started to listen to it. I hope that it finishes the 500 some parts because I love just imagining the process of if you do one wrong move and have to do everything ever so perfectly. Great series and can’t wait to see more parts!!!

Please tell me the Holders 13-18 is the last if this crap . The podcast is 5 stars if you just skip over this series. I’m not going to lower to 4 stars because everyone makes mistakes.