This group has got it going on. Collectively, I am blown away by the amount of intelligence and well researched cases. Keep it up:).

I love that there is cases I’ve never heard before. Sometimes true crime redoes the same things always but you guys bring new cases to the light and teach me new things!

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Love this podcast and hearing all of the different takes on the crimes and punishments. Matt is hilarious, juls is a great addition to the team and is there anything Lisa can’t do? Great stories and even better hosts!

You guys should check out Shawn’s you give page. He makes videos all day every day about Natalie even in 2020

Voices are hard to listen to and too many disclaimers.

Your ad intro scared the bejesus outta me! Please tone it down!

Terrible audio. The hosts are puerile and will hurt your eardrums.

Id rather have kidney stones again than to ever listen to this podcast again.

Interesting cases. Love these two. But Matt speak up! Sometimes I can barely hear you.

I went to high school with tommy Schaefer and it was such a shock to everyone that grew up with him bc he was not that kind of person. He was cool with literally everyone. After his girlfriend Rachel died right after high school in (car accident I’m Africa) he LOST it! That’s when he started dating heather and everyone knew heather was crazy af! It’s so sad that they did this! Heather is a master manipulator and always has been. But I’m pretty sure once then get back to the US they will be charged here too bc Sheila was a socialite. I have both of them on social media and tommy is super apologetic on Facebook but heather seems to not care most the time and acts like she’s living the life in prison. Just sick. I feel so bad for Stella. I enjoyed listening to this considering I know tommy personally.

it took me a while to determine if this was a serious podcast or a complete joke. The worst content the worst audio, I don’t even understand what I’m listening to... it is a true crime to be this bad at podcasting

I love the show! My only complaint is that Matt tends to have no idea that his audio level goes wayyy up when he yells into the mic. So, I do understand the other complaints about this. Matt, ya gotta pay attention to those audio levels. Other than that, I love the show. ❤️ pleeeeeeease come back!

I will admit that I only listened to about 3/4 of the episode related to Darlie Routier before I had to just stop. It was too painful to listen to all of her inaccuracies. And the vocal fry. Oh, the poor vocal chords. When you can’t even get the ages of the victims correct, that’s inexcusable. The victims were 5 and 6 years old; not 4 and 7. How hard is that? She didn’t report she was not awakened by a perpetrator sitting on top of her. She reported she was awakened by her son nudging her shoulder and saying “Mommy”. As a matter of fact, one of the biggest sources of contention during her testimony was her insisting that she did not recall any of the attack at all and used the word “frightened” not “fighting” on the 911 tape. The prosecution was insistent that she had conflicting reports and said that she was fighting the perpetrator when she was insistent that she did not recall the perpetrator attacking her or the boys. What about the evidence that the inside of her mouth was sore and bruised which was documented by the nurses at Baylor? There is speculation that chloroform was used and explains the lack of awareness and sleeping through the attack. Where is that information? The fibers that were found on the knife were never matched to the window screen. That’s a rumor. Read the transcript. They are speculated to have come from fingerprint dust. Did you even listen to the 911 tape? Did you read the trial transcript? It’s available for you to read. I don’t really care which side of this you fall on, at least report the facts correctly. To take on the responsibility of a true crime podcast and report inaccuracies and false information is irresponsible. Hearing more about your feelings and reactions more than facts that were involved in the case is a waste of time. Now, drink some water, rest your vocal cords and find something else to do with your time because you’re clearly wasting it.

I listened to the episode regarding Ted Binion. The female lead knew NOTHING about this case. She basically read from a google search which was completely inaccurate. She then didn’t understand what she just read. She also giggles way to much and acts as if her stupidity is entertaining. I would of liked to hear the male leads position, but she does not let him speak. The caller from Vegas was somewhat knowledgeable but again the chick would not let her speak. I couldn’t get through the episode. Painful Podcast.

I’m on episode 12 and the sound that had been low quality has gotten so much better. I do think Matt’s voice sounds like Todd Lowe from Gilmore Girls. 😂 Thanks for a different spin on gruesome cases!

I can’t even focus on the story because of her voice fry. Nails on a chalkboard.

Audio is pretty bad and hard to understand the man.

I enjoy the topics but the audio is bad and they talk over each other which makes it hard to hear.

How the hell have you been doing this for over a year, and your audio sounds like a banshee screaming into a microphone? Figure it out,buy some ACTUAL equipment and keep the screaming out of it. My ear drums are bleeding from the woman thinking that SCREAMING INTO THE MICROPHONE IS CUTE with the additon of vocal fry. Also, have the guy not smoke an pound of pot before he records. He sounds obliviouis. Go back to the drawing board and try it again, or better yet... call it quit.

Love this podcast. Great hosts

A lot goes into these podcasts in terms of research and smart discussions over the crime, the morality, punishment, etc. Definitely has my attention and I am into listening to true crime podcasts!

They just talk back and forth. Not facts. It’s a bunch of “oh, I didn’t know that!”, and “oh, I didn't hear that about the case...” Opinions are fine, but if that’s all you do, and you go back and forth, then it’s not interesting. The sound quality is also very terrible. The girl seems to want to talk over everyone. Had to delete. Sorry.

The two hosts talk to much and not a lot of info, it seems like they don't know what they're talking about. Would not recommend!!! -2 stars ✨ definitely one of the worst true crime podcasts out there

Update: Still loving this show and can’t wait to collaborate with Lisa! Stay tuned! Seriously; I think we just became best friends! Every episode I listen to is just another confirmation of how alike we are! I love that I can literally be thinking of a response or have a reaction to something and Lisa has that same reaction; it’s awesome! The dynamic between Lisa and Matt makes for such an easy listen...I really feel as though I’m hanging out with my friends! Keep it up you two! I’m loving every minute! -Heather (Nature vs Narcissism & Status Pending Podcasts)

Love the energy,the logo is trippy,and you can tell they like talking TC!

Im so glad i found this podcast! I have binge listened to date and am so anxious for the next episde! Lisa and Matt do such a great job hosting and the research is obviously greatly done! Id highly reccomend Eye for an Eye to ANYONE! -Nicki T (StrictlyHomicide)

I really enjoy this podcast. Compassion, passion and good commentary. I like the concept of this show.

I like tuning into this show, because the dynamic between Lisa and Matt is good, plus the Streamin and Screamin shows are fun to listen to. Congrats on the new network, too!

Great show. Keep up the good work!

I listen to a lot of true crime/ murder podcasts and I love the way these gals mix it up.

to be or not to be?

Tried to listen to the uber episode sounds like it was recorded by two four year olds. Clowns

Eye for an eye is one of my new favorite true crime podcasts!

Just listened to the Utterly Ridiculous Minisode and it was seriousy ridiculous and fun! Matt and Lisa have great energy. They would be fun to listen to on a long drive.

The cohosts have a great energy together and the podcast is such an awesome twist on the traditional true crime story telling format. It asks one of the most important questions in our justice system, does the punishment fit the crime?

I love this show! Lisa and Matthew not only give you a thorough review of some of the most intriguing true crime cases in the hoistory of the justice system. They also are not to wrappend up in being serious and have a good time and are able to make jokes at times to deal with the dark and serious nature of the topics they discuss. When you talk about the ark and tragic events they talk about being able to lightne the mood with some jokes are not disrespectful but is entertaining and necessary to make sure the topics they are taeching us about are also able to be talked about without driving their listeners into a depressive dark hole. If you have thin skin or take yourslef to seriously or cannot realize that being offended or disrespected is a individual issue and not the intent of this great show than you need to take a long look in the mirror at yourself.

I love this podcast and I really love the chemistry between the two hosts. Not only is the podcast factual, but I love the bits of comedy thrown in by Lisa and Matt.

It’s nice that hear some cases I’ve never heard of.

Such a great podcast I binged listened!

Lisa is thoroughly researched on all the case details and does tons of research. I’ve heard her mention it in several episodes that she combs through every article, audio file, image, etc. she can find to compare and contrast the in/consistencies. I mean...does Matt even help? Or is he the token super-charming charismatic background vampire that every podcast needs?!

Love this pod!! The hosts have great chemistry and are super funny, plus they do not skimp on the details and do great research! Keep up the amazing work!!

Fun younger perspective on a true crime podcast.

Great content and interesting stories. You guys keep me up at night seriously some scary stuff this world can be freighting and you guys display that perfectly

The content is great, I just can’t get over the sound quality. It’s very echoey and sounds like you’re very far from your mics. Hopefully as you get bigger you can have professional audio edits. *coming back after the shout out. Glad you guys take the time to read and reply to your reviews! I myself am looking to start a podcast and I’ve started a lot of research on equipment. I’d love to connect and share some info plus i can possibly get you all a discount on equipment. My husband works for a fairly large corporate electronics company.

I love this podcast, it's very informative and I love the hosts personalities

Found you guys on Facebook and I am happy to say I found a new podcast for my morning commute. I’ll definitely be back. Thanks guys.

This podcast is great, I love true crime and it’s the only one I’ll listen to. They always give an in-depth background of the case (with most crime podcasts I feel like I can find more information by reading about it myself) and it’s a good balance of opinion and fact. Please keep the episodes coming!

Just found this podcast and have been binge listening ever since. You can tell how passionate the hosts are about true crime as well as how well researched their information is. Looking forward to hearing many more!

Finally a podcast that discusses the part of the case that makes me wanna scream the most- did the justice system get it right!?! I love that this podcast covers both popular cases that (I thought) I already had a strong opinion on and also little known cases! Bravo!