If you are a fan of EDH you will love this podcast!

I listen to every episode. You all do a great job! I have a suggestion for a series of topics. I would love to get a comprehensive breakdown of Richard’s ramp packages for each color & archetypes within colors and philosophy for how to make them work.

Great podcast the host is very knowledgeable. Good podcast for anybody who plays magic the gathering

Listen to it every day

Let’s go mtggoldfish I have never seen crim’s corgis but I want to!!

My commander decks are: atraxa poison, Tergrid, Jodah, Sen triplets, and my favorite troll deck rakdos group hug

The best mtg podcast because nobody agrees.

Crim is annoying

Great show

I love the story's from the viewers. they are so funny too. Once, when i was just getting into commander i was playing an enchantments precon deck. It was at my casual local game store and when i get to the pod they are playing tier 1 decks and they notice im new to the game so they don't really target me, so when i pulled off a combo that milled other people’s decks for each enchantment and everyone else was playing a bunch of draw spells and when they lost they got super salty and i never saw them again.

Great personalities, information, and entertainment! I love this podcast.

I love to listen to this show while I am bored and it’s fun, there is a lot of personality between all the people, and you can see the color they play come out in their bias and everyone else just jokingly hates on them, but you can tell they just enjoy talking about their favorite game.

I love the “our favorite ___” episodes, I had a game where someone played an atraxa, as soon as they did the other 5 people started discussing how to deal with it, I convinced them to let me hit it with fractured identity, the guy who played it lasted 2 more turn cycles.

Great personalities

Great topics. Interesting discourse. I just wish Richard wasn’t apart of it. Something about his voice makes me want to take a hammer and nail to each ear drum.

Dont have anything personal against him but I don’t think Tomer likes this game very much. Love everybody on the show though.

The Mtggoldfish crew is great and provides many hours of not only entertainment but also fantastic deck building advice. I also appreciate the range in play level they discuss, from S tier cEDH all the way down to the “unplayables.” Thank you so very much for hours of entertainment both in my ears and also my eyes on YouTube. Clash on!!!!!!

I used to not like this podcast, but once I listened to a full episode I was hooked.

I lost a game yesterday to what my opponent flipped a bomb off my chaos warp. Tomer speaks the truth.

Have you sign in blood someone to death, if u haven’t u haven’t lived. Sign in blood

It too often feels like the other guys are (rightfully) coming down on Richard for his hot takes that just distract from the conversation. Each episode it feels like Richard brings some new indefensible opinion that Crim, Seth, and Tomer have to try and talk him out of. Tolarian Academy unbanned? The back and forth doesn’t feel productive and Richard’s opinions made me no longer listen

Woof! I was hoping this would be a fun show. It it’s a lot of dudes having an equipment measuring competition. “No no I have the more fringe edgelord opinion!” “No I do!!” “I’m so non conformist you guys! Pay attention to me!!” I like it when people go against the grain. Have interesting if not obscure deck ideas. Why I like Commander Quarters and the like. But not when you make it your whole personality. Like dang who didn’t take y’all to prom?

This is a great podcast, very informative on EDH with four hosts with different play styles. You get a breakdown on each topic with a different perspective for different play styles, not just a generic subject assessment.

Topics vary every week. Discussion sometimes feels like too many chefs in the kitchen. Team feels quite knowledgeable on the subjects, but debates can turn to who is individually and technically correct instead of seeking the the best collective answer.

Tomer and the gang bring it home when it comes to commander content. Super enjoyable and jank. What more could you want? Also MTGgoldfish is the GOAT

The only the this cast needs is sick intro and outdo music! Keep it up.

Richard seems to be on of those l enchanting people that just says contrary nonsense for the sake of being contrary. Either that or he is a simpleton. And my goodness, enough with the whining, either stop playing magic or adopt a slightly more positive attitude. The rest of the gentleman are alright, just not Richard and his candy-coated brain.

I barely play mtg anymore but they make it fun to keep up with the hobby anyways! Yeah hank you Seth, Tomar, Crim, and my favorite jank player, Richard. Keep it up guys!

Topics are in depth and covered from many different angles in a light hearted but critical way. The wonderful cast and group dynamic is the cherry on top to an A1 podcast. Thank you!