This podcast brings me so much joy. I love the friendship, the happiness…despite the heaviness of the topic, it gives me the warm fuzzies! Thanks for sharing yourselves with us! ❤️❤️

Ellyn and Joey were guests on Let’s Go To Court and I immediately loved them! They are funny and smart and the exact adhd theater nerds that I love! So glad I’ve found them and I love their accountability vibe.

I love this podcast!! Ellyn & Patrick are priceless & Joey is so hot & awesome!! Love you guys!!

Please no rabia, not sure how she can solve a case if she doesn’t think adnan did it

I’m only here for Ellyn. Ellyn is everything! Joey is childish and not funny. Don’t care that your gay. I just don’t want to hear about “butt stuff” for an hour. I miss the Patrick days. Ellyn… I could listen to you channel Sharon all day. PS I’ll change my review when Joey grows up.

Ellyn and Joey are excellent together, perfect combination of levity, respect, and the kind of refreshingly genuine tense moments that you can only get from BFFs. They challenge each other and we all get to reap the rewards. Unfortunately there are so many ads, I’m suspicious that it’s to cover the drop in interest in Obsessed, which has really gone downhill. Let Ellyn and Joey do their thing with fewer interruptions!

They authenticity isn’t there! Feels like a knock off TCO. Wouldn’t listen at all

Thank you so much to A Date with Dateline for tagging this podcast on your Instagram feed. Joey and Ellyn are a riot! With living in New York now, I love all the references to Broadway even more as the palate cleansers. Their reviews and recaps of the various shows are spot on. I wish I gotten to see you guys in kinky boots! 5 stars.

On planet earth. Super genuine hosts. Super amazing stories & discussions. Overall no notes.

First saw them as a “drag along” at a live show. I have binged every episode since Joey started and am a huge fan since seeing them live. Come back to Arizona for a show (come to Tucson)!!

Just FYI: <1% Norway population is of African decent.

As a trump loving conservative from the south, I can verify that Joey has a great Butt! Truly this is such a great listen. Two great people that always deliver comedy with beautiful heartfelt moments. Ellyn and Joey are just good people.

Good show by good people who lead by example, live with authenticity, and genuinely strive to make the world a better place. Give Tucker a mic, he’s got a lot to say!

I started binging this show a few weeks ago when they did a crossover with LGTC, and I’ve been obsessed. I started at the beginning, and although I miss that other lady who used to be on the show, I also love the chemistry between Ellyn and Joey! These two have great banter, and they bring a much appreciated lightness to the dark episodes they cover while being sensitive to the victims and their families. I’m obsessed with Ellyn’s rants. Keep going girl! I’ll pull over any time for you! I’m going to be so sad once I am caught up and don’t have any episodes left to binge. I may just have to join the Patreon for all the bonus episodes and Joey’s nudes. DB for life!

I have been listening to this from the very beginning. This is my go to podcast. I love every moment of these episodes and they keep me company on my drives to and from school and to my clinical rotations. I usually tell me wife that I’m going to hang out with Ellyn and Joey on my ride home!! There isn’t an episode that I’m not in stitches laughing about. I have an entire note in my notes app devoted to Ellyn sayings!! I feel like I could be best friends with Ellyn and Joey!! Their personalities are infectious. I just love them both so much!! This will forever be my favorite podcast, please don’t ever stop!! 🫶🏼🫶🏼

Your friendship, your back and forth with one another makes me laugh. It keeps me coming back day after day. Thank you!

i love this podcast so much ellyn and joey do an AMAZING job at giving you details about the cases but also lighten it up with hilarious jokes and bits. i appreciate all the work they put into this podcast, it's definitely one i recommend to people🫶🏼

Ellyn and Joey you are amazing. Only miserable people complain but still listen. Y’all keep my work days better. Love you guys

Ellyn and Joey are truly some of the best hosts of true crime podcasts. They have created an amazing show and it’s the highlight of my week. I recently had a chance to see their live show too and they really do give great hugs and take the time to meet each and every DB.

Joey is the best!!

Love these two. Funny and sometimes the episode includes a little beautiful singing.

Omg! The Reality Gays with Ellen and Joey was perfection! Please do more episodes with them. I have not laughed so hard in awhile. Thank you!

The worst drama kids energy all the time. So much screeching, in-jokes, “got to be on,” and can’t stay on topic. So disappointing.

Joey and Ellyn are everything you want in a true crime comedy podcast. They are respectful of the material and the victims but find the comedy in things like the production quality and the talking heads who say ridiculous things. I love these too much that I can’t stand it! In person at their live shows, they will stay for HOURS to hug every single person who wants to. That’s how you know they are good people. You two deserve all the happiness and success!

love the hosts but the jokes got too inappropriate for me- keep slaying tho!

I love it!

Joey talking about lady parts was hilarious 😂

Back to listening to you!

Need I say more!!! If you are looking for a laugh, look no further. Yes, it’s a true crime comedy podcast & it’s not as gauche as it sounds. They have figured out a way to honor the memory of the victims, while making fun of the “non” DBs while recapping true crime shows… You’ll get that DB reference once you start listening… 🙌🙌🙌 Love it!!!

I found ITN in the fall of 2023 and it has quickly become my favorite true crime podcast. Ellyn and Joey are friends in real life and their endless banter reflects that. They research the stories before they record each show, which I really appreciate. You’ve gained a long term listener!

Ellyn and Joey are such a great combination! I look forward to hearing every episode they do! One of my favorites!

This is a great show, especially once Joey joins. They go off topic, but it’s only to lighten the very serious moments. However, every case is treated with respect for the victims, heroes, and horrendous stories. Their banter is hilarious and, at times, heartwarming. Cannot recommend enough.

How can Joey’s ‘butt’ be sore from any medical procedure given ‘things’ are ‘inserted’ into his ‘butt’ on a regular basis? Please clarify. Help me understand. It makes no sense.

Cringe worthy, problematic and offensive from beginning to end. There are no winners here. This podcast is just as awful as the rest on this garbage network.

The end. That’s it.

A favorite!

One of the best podcasts out there.. keep up the good work!!! I love you guys.

Dear Ellyn and Joey, Please keep doing what you are doing with ITN. Also, we need one more podcast from you, focusing only on Love After Lock-up. Your patreon episodes of Love After Lock-up are SO FUNNY, and I want more!!!

This podcast has gotten me through many a gym session, commute and house clean. Live the chemistry with these two!

I love you two SOOOO much !!!!!!!!!!! Much needed laughs in this crazy world!!!!!

Listening to these two are like sitting down for the tea with my besties. Their banter, bits and singing make this podcast my favorite. Highly recommend!

I cackle while running, grocery shopping, driving and cleaning and listening to this show. ❤️

I love all the true crime podcasts I listen too!! but I love I Think Not!!! The most!! Ellyn and Joey are wonderful people and I enjoy their singing, banter and most of all how they are soo much alike!!!

There may be a little comedy here and there, but absolutely NEVER about the victim or crimes against them. They help break the tension by the little things, like messing up words and teasing one another. their dynamic makes you feel like you are right there and you can’t help but giggle too. But also don’t forget about the times I’ve literally laughed out loud crying from the humor. I can’t express the love I have for Ellyn and Joey and thank them for being themselves and bringing some more joy into the world.

Love Joey and Ellyn. Always funny, always respectful to families and victims. Always a great time.

Joey has some amazing voices that just get me laughing, real good! Love that he doesn’t care about being silly and is at 💯

Unite! I love this podcast. Maybe 50% because I ALSO HAVE A LOLA GRACE. Back to you; I am always laughing out loud. Oh I — sorry — I have a call coming in. One sec. Ok, I’m back. Sorry; that was my previous favorite podcast.

I look forward to this podcast every week. I miss a lot of it from laughing and am constantly rewinding. My 82 year old mother also think they are hysterical.

Every time I hear Joey’s voice I crave macaroni. Not sure what that’s about… FIVE STARS!

Sometimes life can be rough These podcasters help make it a bit better. They deal with serious topics; they are always kind to victims and their families, and they are a lot of fun about things typically outside of true crime to keep things respectful