I love that the stories aren’t well know stories. Great job!

I literally listen to these guys my whole 8 hour shift every single day 😅

Great job!

Listen to all the podcasts and Patreon episodes can't get enough!

Come to FL

I love James and Jimmie! The story telling is genuine and thorough. They’re serious when they say they don’t make jokes about the victims or their families which I appreciate. But I REALLY appreciate the comedic relief and calling out of horrible people 🤣

I'm a nurse on light duty from a knee injury, so instead of taking care of my icu patients I'm doing data entry for HR... I have adhd and the constant sitting and boring work was KILLING ME. But my friend reminded me about STM and I started listening again. Making my office days so much better!!!

Just in time for WV’s birthday.

I don’t know what I’m doing!!!

So I truly love this show you guys are a riot. You’ve captured the essence of my humor. I finally joined the show, but here’s my problem, you stated my real name rather than my online persona, this was totally my fault as I was stoned, and then passed out and never finished changing my name so you would be able to say, my awesome online name. If I go up a level, will my name be shouted out again. If you guys ever find yourself in the 802, we should connect. I would love for you to indulge in some of our green mountain loveliness chill by the fire and talk comedy crime. You guys are definitely invited to the barbecue.

Thanks for always keeping me entertained 🩷

I think I’m in love with Jimmie Whisman, and James is so smart and funny

It gets old them talking about how they are better than everyone else and every town. They talk about politics every show after telling you they don’t talk about politics. Also spend a lot of time not talking about the actual topics of the show.

Very well researched , yet hilarious!

Great concept. Excellent execution. 😂

I work in a retirement home and shout SHUT UP AND GIVE ME MURDER at the residents

I watch all 3 shows, super funny and entertaining

Don’t trust the murder ficus

These two guys are pretty cool! I absolutely love the humor in the show! I have been listening for a long time playing catch up but man oh man I feel like hanging with these guys would be so chill! Catch a vibe listen to a great podcast

Love you Jimmy, but please speak up! I want to hear what you're mumbling. 😅

I listen to all your shows :)

Love you both, thanks for always hanging with me at work.

It’s just too good. Con’s: I’m just now finding it. Pros: so much content to listen too. I love a good liverwurst sandwich!

I love this show.

Love these guys. Keep the jokes among the tragedy coming.

As a now retired CSI, we used to say this all the time and it seems appropo here. Love the stories, keep up the great work!

All of their shows are funny. I sit in my chair at work and say SHUT UP AND GIVE ME MURDER!! My coworker knows it’s the beginning of a new episiode.

But holy moly, you guys are amazing! A

🤭

True crime and comedy should always go together!!

Crime in sports.

I drive for work and I am so thankful for you both! You always make me laugh!! Thank you for all the work you put into the show. You both keep me sane!

It’s just about a perfect show.

If you’re not listening, you’re missing out on the best true crime stories.

Comedy with true crime is awesome

You guys are the best!

Love this podcast, and all they do. Local FedEx guy…..in a neighborhood near you….😂

Love you both. Thanks for making me laugh so hard.

Great show

I’ve Pavlov’d myself into only being able to fall asleep to these 2 weirdos voices.

This show is one of the best podcasts out there If you have a sense of humor and enjoy true crime give any episode a listen

I just began listening to this and I started from the beginning! I am only on Episode 104. I am obsessed I have never laughed out loud, by myself so hard!!! I listen on the bus on my headphones and other passengers stare because I fight giggles all of the time. Nothing gets me in a good mood like Jimmie’s Andrew Jackson comments or when James says something that makes Jimmie almost have a stroke!!! Please keep this up forever…I need it everyday!!! PS It made put a title, but so far…5 stars for all of them!!!

The show is awesome. The hosts are awesome. Listen to it.

I started listening to STM 8/2022. I’m not gonna say that this Podcast and these two host saved my life. But they have definitely changed my life for the better between their three podcast and their Patreon, (which is the best five dollars you’ll ever spend). I wake up to the episodes, go about my day listening to them, and fall asleep and take naps to it. I rewind and replay also as I’ve caught up on all the episodes by listening 1.5x speed. The way they research and go back later to do catch ups on murders and athletes (and now businesses) is so engrossing! Whenever some is vexxing me I’m able to calm down by pressing play on James and Jimmie. Thanks guys!

Thanks James and Jimmie for getting me through long work days!

Hello. My favorite tea is oolong.

Blue, purple, pink

Started from the beginning, love it!

Five stars. Would give more if I could.

Great job. Excellent format. Funny! 😃👏🏾👏🏾