Bill, we need a breakdown.

Simmons, Ryan and Fennesy are awesome together. I love when Russillo and Van are on too. They really need to start doing TV shows too.

I have learned a lot from listening to this pod and watched a lot of movies and gone down a lot of rabbit holes, it’s all been great. Excellent pod, BUT The “I’m the only black guy on a podcast with all white people” bit The “I’m a married woman but I want to have sex with Harrison Ford” bit And lastly, The “unnecessary sports reference” bit All get realllllllly old :)

There is no toll road near Muncie Indiana. Close encounters of the third kind

Bill, stay behind the scenes. You’ve hired great people-CR, Jo, Van; Bill is a “know it all” in his mind only. These Star Wars episodes really missed having someone old enough to remember this movie when it was released. Sorry Bill, you weren’t.

THRILLED that they finally bit into Star Wars!! The show is great fun to listen to if you’re into movies. Some of the choices are baffling but you can’t please everyone so I get it. My own wish list: Aliens (did the first one but more people love the second one) The Matrix Blade Runner Braveheart The Thing Conan the Barbarian Event Horizon LOTR? (probably wishful thinking) Anyway, it’s a great pod with funny and insightful content. I really don’t get all the negativity about Van in other reviews. He makes intelligent comments and the episodes he’s on are great. Thumbs up.

Amazing episode until the behind the scenes “Mic Guy” oks killing CEOs. Too bad.

I wish he was in every ep

This is easily my favorite podcast series. And Bill, you opened the door…now The Rewatchables absolutely must do Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi.

He ruins every episode he’s on.

How is Animal House still on the board??

Noooooo way?!? How did you get Bill to do it!? May the Force be with you Bill.

Have you ever thought of reviewing a Director and all their movies? Currently listening to Star Wars and you are talking about all the directors of that era.. would be neat to hear a full episode director specific…

This used to be my favorite podcast but it’s not as good anymore. It makes sense. Over time they just ran out of rewatchable movies to talk about. Once they started doing movies like “Pump Up the Volume” which was literally unwatchable at the time because it wasn’t on any platform to watch when they did it and started doing theme months that included “Manchester By The Sea” it got really hard to listen to. (Note: This is a phenomenal movie but is definitely NOT rewatchable) I love the recent episodes with Kyle Brandt doing more cause he brings a different, incredible energy but if he’s not involved it’s usually a pass at this point for me. Check out their earlier episodes. They’re way better.

Entertaining, funny, and sometimes insightful. I enjoy the podcast, but there is a lot of sexism. Particularly the episodes with no women. I don’t think it’s consciously done, but talking about actresses being hot enough for roles, pretty consistently talking about how terrible female characters are, disregarding movies that are typically geared towards women - it all adds up. I’d suggest adding some other voices to the discussion and thinking a little harder about the unconscious bias coming through.

I would love to see you guys do these 5 movies: Dirty Harry High Fidelity 30 Days of Night The Birdcage 28 Days Later

The categories are impeccable. The sports comparisons are colliding my two worlds perfectly. Van’s “did this movie need more black people?” And “WHY MEL, WHY?!” cries always crack me up! This podcast is endless entertainment. 10/10.

Very funny and entertaining pod, would be a 5 star but Mallory Rubin’s annoying voice brings it down 2 stars!

Stumbled into this, now we are sprinting!!! The Ben, Kyle and Ryne combo is pure entertainment!! Time for gymkata, out for justice and KKIII.. keep banging out top shelf work

Thank you Bill, Sean, and Chris! Can a long time fan since the Boston Phoenix articles make two requests? 1. Can we ( I say we) Re- The Warriors (love Shea but he didn’t like the movie) or 2. Let Kyle and Mallory cook independently for the Lord of the Rings trilogy I know Chris and Sean have Xmas connection, but Mal and Kyle are passionate about it. Thank you for all the free content, insightful break downs, inside jokes, and endless laughs!!! You guys are the best!!!

Pod was a must listen w Bill, Chris & Sean!

This is not a review, it’s a suggestion. It’s a classic with Sean Penn, Robin Wright, Gary Oldman and Ed Harris.

Hey Bill, how’s that massive doge dong taste? Listening to Bill and Chris compare the dystopia of fight club to January 6 is comedic, genius, or just two crybabies who suffered from TDS. How’s that playing out for you guys in 2025? Poor sweethearts, always gotta bring politics into everything. This podcast was good, until you both went full, “the view”, on me. JFC, get a grip.

Elisabeth Shue has not won an Oscar. How do you guys make that mistake more than once?

If Van is involved. I’m out. Sick of the perpetual racism talk

editors note: I am actually giving this show SIX stars specifically for Van clearing out the riffraff. 🤠 Legitimately I had no idea who Bill was but he brings a lot of my favorite people on to talk about films that I should know about (but don’t because I was raised in a cult!) so here I am! ☺️

...the one dude who finds it funny to obnoxiously yell and cuss is utterly irritating. Also, Van is getting tedious with his cussing and race talk. Sick of the race stuff. Otherwise, a great show with great viewpoints. The show is very well organized and thought out except for that one guy who finds it funny to yell at the top of his lungs while cursing up a storm. That's when I sometimes turn it off because he goes on and on with it. Really could do without that. Also, I hate the live shows. They always play it up for the audience in the stands, and it is annoying.

So close to a great show. Always enjoyable aside from the one guy who insists on screaming his annoying “impressions” that all sound the same.

That’s it. That’s the review. No more Van!

I wish Bill would let someone else pick the movies once in a while; “Crash,” “Project X,” “Devil’s Advocate,” and “Blackhat” were all terrible movies.

The show is good but Van’s episodes are a skip. He goes on and on with no endless racial blather and dumb comics references.

Big fan of The Rewatchables podcast. The Days of Thunder episode was a 10/10 - perfection. Incredible energy, great takes, excellent insights. Bill, CR & Kyle made this podcast so enjoyable. Love Craig’s insights as well. Maybe the Days of Thunder title had nothing to do with the screen movie and was describing Jerry/Don’s lifestyle during the shoot? Anyway, keep up the amazing work!!

You guys are great, all of you!! Rewatchable suggestion: Funny Farm!

Love the podcast. But can Simmons not be on every single one? I have your takes down. Might be nice to hear someone else. I want you on most of them but sometimes I could use a new take. Your Marvel takes are boring. We get it. I’m not a huge fan of Marvel, but to pretend they don’t exist is exhausting.

Find a movie you adore and listen to clever, funny movie enthusiasts dissect the film in insightful, humorous ways. After a while you’ll pick out the good cohosts (CR, Sean, Kyle Brandt, Van Lathan, Serrano) from the ones to avoid (Mallory Rubin).

I love this podcast. It always provides lots of entertainment, even if I haven’t seen the film. I am also leaving a review of five stars because there are so many crybaby right wing douche bags, whining in the comments and low ranking the Pod. Wahhhhh!

Love the Rewatchables. Van has me skipping episodes when he is involved. I don’t believe my post will make much of an impact but many others have the same take. Love the show though….

He blathers on and on with nothing funny or insightful to say. Also, not everything is about race.

Shows ok but can’t stand Van. Big shock, all he talks about is race. It is pathetic and such a beta male thing. They will never give him the boot though because they have to “check the box”.

Crash podcasts was terrible had to turn it off after 30 minutes

So many times while listening I want to throw my phone across the room. Latest time: Maura Tierney played Annabelle in The Replacements, not Brooke Langdon!!!!

Great podcast, definitely geared towards movie buffs and cinephiles like me!

Constantly bringing up cocaine in every pod is very annoying

Just listened to the "Before Sunset" pod...just incredible! I'm 54 and these movies were so integral to my youth and view on relationships/that quest for the one...the soulmate. Quick question, was I the only one who watched "Thirtysomething" in high school and wanted a Hope as a future wife?

Unless you have seen the film they are discussing 20 times you can't follow along and the tangents are eye-rolling

Mallory ruins this one with just awful input that’s clearly informed by the third film (which is her favorite). Takes away from the magic that the second film has

LA Confidential???

CR, please do this!

In the mailbag episode a listener claimed it wasn’t piano wire but a saw at the end of Hereditary. It actually was piano wire. Recommend referring to original scripts for fact checking: “As Peter enters the hallway, a SHARP CLANGING SOUND is heard downstairs. Peter freezes. A sustained REVERB fills the house. It sounded like it came from a piano.” “Peter notices the PIANO. It seems to have been tampered with. The lid is open and a couple of the wires have been SNAPPED.” “ANNIE is huddled up into a corner of the ceiling. Her face is twisted with grief and fear, and she is shaking her head - “no, no, no, no, no” - as if pleading with the back of Peter’s head, like a frightened animal. She holds PIANO WIRE, pulling it taut with both hands. Wringing blood.” “ANNIE has somehow gotten in. She floats weightlessly in the air. (She is faintly illuminated by a candle below her.) She has looped the PIANO WIRE around her own NECK, which is already straining blood. She TUGS on one end of the wire. It SAWS through her neck. She TUGS on the other end of the wire. It saws even deeper.”

Great pod, but the 80’s cocaine jokes from Bill are tiresome. We get it, cocaine was big in the 80’s, but mentioning it on every pod makes one think he may or may not partaken more than once. Leave it alone, dude.